Category: Learning Science Toolkit

  • Five Studies That Shaped My Thinking About Training

    Five Studies That Shaped My Thinking About Training

    When training fails, our first instinct is often to add something.

    Another explanation. Another example. Another module. Maybe a quiz with three answers nobody could possibly get wrong.

    But what if content isn’t the problem?

    I recently reviewed 50 studies from psychology, behavioral science, and learning research. I chose them for their influence, historical value, and usefulness at work.

    Several of them highlight that training isn’t always the answer.

    Here are five that changed how I think about performance.

    Get the complete 50-study field guide

    Want the other 45? I compiled all 50 studies, along with their limitations, workplace applications, and practical ideas, into a free field guide.

    ​

    ​

    A layout problem can become a learning problem

    Picture a diagram on one side of a screen and its explanation on the other. Your eyes bounce back and forth. Meanwhile, your brain tries to hold one piece in memory while searching for the next. That mental juggling has a cost. Paul Chandler and John Sweller called it the split-attention effect. When people must combine related information from different places, the layout itself can interfere with learning.

    Split attention—and related attention problems—can appear when we:

    • Put a legend far from the visual it explains
    • Separate instructions from the task
    • Make employees switch between systems to assemble one answer
    • Show visuals that compete with the narration
    • Add decoration that steals attention

    The lesson is not “make everything shorter.” It is this:

    Make important relationships easier to see.

    Try this: Find one screen that separates information people must understand together. Put those pieces side by side—but don’t duplicate information that already makes sense on its own. ​

    ​

    Remembering beats reviewing

    Rereading feels productive.

    The words look familiar. The page makes sense. We nod along and mistake recognition for mastery.

    Then we need the information three days later—and it has vanished.

    Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke compared repeated study with retrieval practice: asking people to recall what they had learned.

    Repeated study performed better after a very short delay. Retrieval produced stronger retention later.

    That difference matters.

    If people need knowledge on the job, they should practice retrieving it from memory—not merely looking it up again.

    A quiz should not be the inspection station at the end of a course. Used well, it can help create the learning.

    Try this: Before reviewing something you have already taught, ask learners to recall it without looking. Then provide the correct answer and useful feedback.

    Effort helps when success is possible and feedback follows. Blind frustration does not.


    Impact becomes real when it has a face

    Organizational psychologist Adam Grant and his colleagues studied university fundraising callers.

    Some callers met a scholarship student whose education had been funded by their work.

    The script stayed the same. So did the pay.

    But the callers could now picture someone who benefited when they picked up the phone. After meeting the student, they worked longer and raised more money.

    Now compare that with the language we often use to introduce workplace training:

    • Maintain compliance
    • Reduce organizational risk
    • Support strategic priorities
    • Complete this requirement by Friday

    Technically accurate. Emotionally dead.

    Grant studied direct contact with a beneficiary, not whether a good story can rescue a dull compliance course. But the design question travels well:

    Can employees see the person their actions affect?

    Who stays safe? Whose work becomes easier?

    Try this: Replace “This training is important because…” with a real example of someone affected by the behavior.

    Don’t just explain the requirement. Give the consequence a face.


    Information cannot fix a friction problem

    Imagine you know exactly what to do.

    Then you meet the form.

    The instructions are vague. The button you need is buried three menus deep. One approval takes four days, and nobody knows who owns it.

    Would another course help?

    Eric Bettinger and his colleagues studied families applying for college financial aid. One group received personalized information. Another received the same information, plus hands-on help completing and submitting the application.

    The help changed behavior. Information alone did much less.

    The workplace parallel is hard to miss. We prescribe training when the real obstacle is:

    • A confusing form
    • A buried button
    • Too many approvals
    • An unclear process
    • A lack of time
    • A system designed like an escape room

    If people already know what to do, more content is unlikely to save the day.

    Try this: Before building training, watch someone perform the task. Count the clicks, decisions, delays, handoffs, and chances to give up.

    You may not have a knowledge problem. You may have a friction problem.

    Sometimes the right intervention is not better instruction. It is fixing the system.


    A badly framed norm can make behavior worse

    In a well-known field experiment, households learned how their energy use compared with their neighbors’.

    The heavy users cut back.

    But some households that had used less energy began using more. Once they saw the average, they drifted toward it even though that meant doing worse.

    A small sign of approval, a smiley face, stopped that boomerang effect.

    Now consider this workplace message:

    Thirty percent of employees still click suspicious links.

    The intended message is clear:

    This behavior needs to change.

    But employees may hear something else:

    Plenty of people do it. I wouldn’t be unusual.

    Never make the behavior you want to stop sound normal.
    When you use a social norm, make it truthful and pair it with clear approval of the desired behavior.

    If your data support it, you might say:

    Most employees report suspicious messages when something doesn’t look right. Thank you for helping protect your coworkers.

    What if the desired behavior is not common yet?

    Don’t invent a statistic. State the standard:

    Reporting a suspicious message is exactly the response we want. Every report helps protect the people around you.

    Try this: Review one message about poor behavior. Does it make the problem sound normal—or the solution?


    The Bottom Line

    These studies examine different problems, but they point in the same direction:

    Performance depends on more than content.
    People must notice what matters. They must recall it when needed, see a reason to act, have a workable path, and believe the behavior belongs here.

    Training can help.

    But it cannot repair a cluttered design, bring an empty mandate to life, remove a broken process, or overpower a culture that rewards the wrong behavior.

    Sometimes the smartest move is to improve the training.

    Sometimes it is to fix what stands in the way.

    What workplace learning problem should I investigate next?

  • The Dual Coding Problem: Why Your Learners Keep Tuning You Out

    The Dual Coding Problem: Why Your Learners Keep Tuning You Out

    How Dual Coding Theory Explains (and Fixes) Your Biggest Learning Design Problem

    Your learners look glazed over. They’re reading ahead while you talk. Or they’ve checked out entirely.

    You know what they’re doing? Choosing.

    Read the slide or listen to you. Not both. They can’t. And it’s not their fault—it’s your design.

    Your Brain Processes Information Through Two Separate Systems

    In 1971, psychologist Allan Paivio proposed dual coding theory. The core insight: your brain has two distinct processing channels. One handles visual and spatial information—images, diagrams, animations. The other handles verbal information—language and words.

    The critical detail most people miss? It’s not about eyes versus ears.

    Text on a slide gets processed through the verbal channel, even though you see it with your eyes. Your brain recodes written words into linguistic form. So when you put bullet points on screen and read them aloud, you’re forcing the verbal channel to process identical information from two sources simultaneously.

    Think of two conveyor belts feeding into working memory. One carries visual representations. The other carries language. When each belt carries complementary information, learning compounds. You get multiple retrieval pathways, stronger encoding, better recall.

    But pack identical information on both belts? The system jams.

    Richard Mayer’s multimedia learning research confirmed this. People learn better from words and pictures together than from words alone—but only when those words and pictures complement rather than duplicate each other.

    The Redundancy Trap

    Most training designers make the same mistake: text on slide, narration reading that text.

    You’ve seen it. Probably done it.

    The problem isn’t repetition for emphasis. The problem is cognitive cost. Your verbal processing system has limited capacity. Force it to handle the same information from two sources—reading and listening—and you max out that capacity on redundant processing. No room left for understanding.

    This is the redundancy effect. Your learners have to choose: read or listen. They read faster than you speak, finish the slide, then wait. You’re talking to people who’ve mentally moved on.

    For novice learners especially, this matters. Experts can handle more complexity. But people learning something new need clean separation between visual and verbal channels.

    Dual Coding Done Right

    This BrightCarbon video demonstrates the difference perfectly.

    First, they show the problem: slides packed with text while narration repeats those exact words. Then they flip it. Visual sequences—diagrams, animations, process flows—paired with narration that explains rather than repeats.

    Watch how it works. The visuals aren’t decorative. They’re not self-explanatory either. You need both channels. What you see plus what you hear creates the complete understanding.

    That’s dual coding working as designed.

    Redesigning Your Materials

    Stop treating slides as a script. They’re a visual partner to your narration.

    Instead of bullet points repeating your words:
    Show diagrams illustrating relationships. Use process flowcharts while you walk through steps verbally. Display before/after comparisons while you explain what changed.

    Instead of definitions on screen:
    Show examples or illustrations while you speak the definition. Visual representation through the eyes, explanation through the ears.

    Instead of spelling out your message:
    Let visuals do visual work and narration do verbal work. Explaining why customer complaints spike in Q4? Show the graph of complaint volume over time. Don’t write “complaints spike in Q4” on the slide. Your words explain why. The visual shows what.

    The principle: related but distinct information through each channel. They support each other, don’t duplicate.

    Try This

    Find one slide where you’re reading on-screen text verbatim.

    Remove that text. Replace it with a visual—diagram, icon, image, data visualization. Practice delivering it with the visual carrying its message while your narration carries yours.

    You’ll know it works when the slide alone doesn’t tell the full story and your narration alone doesn’t paint the full picture. Together, they create understanding neither could achieve alone.

    That’s how your learners’ brains want to process information. Stop fighting it.


    References:

    • Paivio, A. (1971). Imagery and Verbal Processes. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
    • Paivio, A. (1986). Mental Representations: A Dual Coding Approach. Oxford University Press.
    • Clark, J. M., & Paivio, A. (1991). Dual coding theory and education. Educational Psychology Review, 3(3), 149-170.
    • Mayer, R. E. (2009). Multimedia Learning (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • Debunking Learning Styles: What The Research Really Says

    Debunking Learning Styles: What The Research Really Says

    You’re in a kickoff meeting. Someone suggests, “Let’s find out everyone’s learning style first. Then we can tailor the training.”

    Heads nod. It sounds thoughtful. It sounds learner-centered.
    And you feel that small, nagging voice: Is this actually a thing?

    If you’ve been in L&D for a while, you’ve probably been in that room.

    It felt like good practice.

    Here’s the hard part:
    Decades of research say it doesn’t actually improve learning.

    This is not a “you’ve been doing everything wrong” moment. It’s a “the field has moved on—and now we get to move with it” moment.

    Let’s unpack why learning styles are so tempting, what the research really says, and what to use instead that does help people learn.

    Why Learning Styles Feel So Right

    The core promise of learning styles is simple and attractive:

    “If we know how someone learns best, we can design just for them.”

    Who wouldn’t want that?

    It also fits a story we like to tell about ourselves:
    “I’m a visual learner.”
    “I’m an auditory learner.”
    It sounds like knowing your Hogwarts house. It gives you an identity.

    From an L&D point of view, it can feel:

    Human.

    Personalized.

    Modern.

    The problem is that the evidence never caught up with the marketing.

    Large reviews—like Coffield et al. (2004) and a widely cited paper from Pashler and colleagues in 2008—have looked for a “learning styles boost” over and over again.

    They didn’t find it.

    What the Research Actually Tested

    Researchers didn’t just ask, “Do people have preferences?” That answer is easy: yes, they do.

    They asked a tougher question:

    “If we match instruction to a person’s preferred learning style, do they learn better than if we don’t?”

    This is sometimes called the “meshing hypothesis.”

    To support learning styles, we’d need to see a clear pattern:

    • Label learners by style (visual, auditory, etc.).
    • Teach some people in their preferred style and some in a non-preferred style.
    • See better test results for the “matched” group.

    Across many studies and reviews, that pattern just doesn’t appear.

    Learners often feel better when things match their preference. But when you look at performance—recall, problem solving, transfer—the “style match” doesn’t provide a consistent boost.

    The careful conclusion from these reviews is:

    There is no strong evidence that designing training to match learning styles improves learning outcomes.

    That’s the myth-busting part.

    Now let’s talk about what to do with it.

    The Hidden Cost of Chasing Styles

    You might be thinking, “Okay, fine. But what’s the harm? Isn’t it at least harmless?”

    Not always.

    Here’s what happens in real L&D work:

    • We spend time building “What’s your style?” quizzes instead of tightening our examples.
    • We create three versions of content—visual, audio, and kinesthetic—instead of creating one clear, well-designed flow.
    • We talk about “styles” in stakeholder meetings instead of talking about spacing, practice, or how this connects to real work.

    The problem isn’t that learning styles are evil.
    The problem is opportunity cost.

    Every hour we invest in a model that doesn’t add value is an hour we don’t spend on things that do.

    So What Should We Do Instead?

    The good news:
    We are not starting from scratch. Learning science has a lot to offer us here.

    We have decades of evidence for strategies that help most learners, across jobs and contexts, without trying to label them.

    Here are a few of the heavy hitters.

    Combine Words and Visuals (Dual Coding)

    People tend to learn better when we pair clear visuals with clear words.

    A simple diagram plus a short explanation.

    A screenshot with a brief, focused caption.

    A process map plus a short story that walks through it.

    Not decoration. Not stock photos.
    Visuals that actually carry meaning.

    Use Worked Examples

    Before you ask a novice to “jump in and try it,” show a complete example.

    A finished email with comments on why it works.

    A full call script with callouts for each step.

    A solved problem with the thinking made visible.

    Research shows that worked examples reduce overload and help people build mental models faster than throwing them into full problems too soon.

    Manage Cognitive Load

    Our learners aren’t broken. Their attention is just busy.

    You can help by:

    • Making one key point per slide.
    • Cutting cute but irrelevant details.
    • Removing extra animations and noise.
    • Using plain language instead of jargon.

    You don’t need a style label to do this. You just need to respect the limits of working memory.

    Use Spaced and Retrieval Practice

    Cramming feels productive. It’s not.

    Two simple shifts make a big difference:

    • Spaced practice: Spread learning over days or weeks instead of one long hit.
    • Retrieval practice: Ask learners to recall information (mini-quizzes, quick scenarios) instead of only re-reading or replaying.

    Meta-analyses on practice testing and spacing show reliable benefits for long-term retention. They’re not flashy, but they work.

    How to Talk About This Without Shaming Anyone

    Here’s the most important part for our field culture:
    Most people who use learning styles do it because they want to help.

    So when you talk about this with stakeholders or peers:

    • Assume good intent.
    • Aim for curiosity, not “gotcha.”
    • Focus on the upgrade: “Here’s something that works even better.”

    You don’t have to call anyone out. You can simply say:

    “The research on learning styles never really held up. Instead of investing in that, we can use strategies like examples, visuals plus words, and spaced follow-ups that have a much stronger track record.”

    You’re not taking something away.
    You’re offering an upgrade.

    The Bottom Line

    Learning styles feel intuitive and kind. They give us labels and the illusion of precision.

    But large reviews—from Coffield and colleagues, from Pashler and others—keep telling us the same thing: matching instruction to a preferred style doesn’t reliably improve learning.

    The real opportunity is not arguing about who is a “visual learner.”
    It’s designing for how learning works:

    • Clear, meaningful visuals plus words.
    • Worked examples before solo practice.
    • Spaced and retrieval practice.
    • Respect for cognitive load.

    You don’t need a style quiz to do that. You just need to shift your time and energy away from labels and toward strategies that actually pay off for your learners.

    Future-you—and your learners—will be glad you did.

  • The Testing Effect: Why Retrieval Practice is Your Most Powerful Learning Tool

    The Testing Effect: Why Retrieval Practice is Your Most Powerful Learning Tool

    The Lie We Tell Ourselves

    Sarah’s quarterly review went well. Her compliance training program had a 94% completion rate. Everyone passed the quiz. Leadership was pleased.

    Three months later, a manager made a comment that clearly crossed the line. Nobody reported it.

    When HR investigated, five employees gave the same answer: “I didn’t know that counted as harassment.” They’d all completed Sarah’s training. Every single one passed the final quiz. They remembered nothing.

    Sarah knew the problem wasn’t her slides. The content was clear. The examples were relevant. The quiz tested the right material.

    The problem was deeper: her learners never actually learned.

    They recognized information during training. They forgot it afterward. And Sarah had no way to tell the difference until it was too late.

    This is the central paradox of workplace training. We measure completion. We get forgetting. We design for immediate performance. We need lasting retention. We think we’re building knowledge. We’re building illusions.

    The solution isn’t better videos or clearer slides. The solution is counterintuitive. Less presenting. More testing.

    How This Fits: Building on What You Know

    If you’ve read earlier articles in this series, you know effective learning often requires productive struggle. We explored how worked examples reduce cognitive load for novices, making complex skills more learnable. We examined how desirable difficulties enhance retention when applied correctly.

    Testing—specifically, retrieval practice—belongs in the desirable difficulties family. It’s harder than reviewing notes. Less comfortable than rereading. And dramatically more effective than both.

    Here’s the key insight: retrieval practice and worked examples aren’t contradictory. They’re complementary partners in a learning sequence.

    Use worked examples when learners face genuinely novel material. Reduce extraneous load. Build initial schemas. Then—and this is critical—use retrieval practice to cement those schemas into long-term memory.

    Think of it as two-stage construction. First, reduce unnecessary difficulty during initial learning. Then introduce productive difficulty during practice. The worked example teaches the concept. The retrieval practice makes it stick.

    Timing matters. Sequence matters. Understanding when to scaffold and when to challenge separates effective training from theater.

    Now let’s examine why retrieval works so powerfully—and why most organizations still aren’t using it.

    The Evidence That Should Have Changed Everything

    In 2006, Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke ran an experiment that should have revolutionized workplace training.

    It didn’t. At least not yet.

    They had college students read passages about sea otters and the sun. After reading, students were randomly assigned to one of two groups:

    Group 1: Study the passage four times  

    Group 2: Study once, then take three practice tests (no feedback)

    Five minutes later, Group 1 crushed it. They recalled more information. This makes intuitive sense—more exposure, more learning, right?

    One week later, both groups returned for a surprise test.

    The results flipped.

    Students who took practice tests remembered 50% more than students who studied repeatedly (Roediger & Karpicke, 2006). Testing once produced better retention than studying four times.

    Let that sink in. The students who studied less remembered more.

    This wasn’t a fluke. The testing effect—also called retrieval practice—has been replicated hundreds of times across different ages, materials, and contexts. The meta-analyses are overwhelming:

    Rowland (2014) analyzed dozens of studies comparing testing to restudying. Medium-to-large effect size (g = 0.50). Adesope et al. (2017) examined 217 studies spanning lab and classroom settings. Testing won consistently. Agarwal et al. (2021) conducted a systematic review focusing specifically on applied educational contexts—real classrooms, not just labs. The effect held.

    The evidence is bulletproof. When you force learners to retrieve information from memory—to actively recall without looking—you create stronger, more durable learning than any passive review strategy.

    But why? What happens during retrieval that makes it so powerful?

    What Retrieval Actually Does to Your Brain

    Most people think of tests as measurement tools. Ways to assess what learners know. But testing is a learning event. The act of retrieval physically changes the brain.

    Let’s experience this directly.

    Try this right now: Without looking back, write down the three groups from the Roediger and Karpicke study I just described. What did each group do?

    Go ahead. Try it.

    Notice what just happened in your mind. You had to search for the information. Maybe you pictured the paragraph where I described it. Maybe you remembered “Group 1 studied more” but couldn’t recall the exact number. Maybe you struggled.

    That struggle? That’s retrieval. And it’s completely different from what happens when you reread.

    Now scroll up and check your answer.

    You just experienced three phenomena that make retrieval practice work:

    The Effort Changes Everything

    When you reread material, your brain takes a shortcut. You see information and think, “Yes, I know this.” You’re using recognition pathways. Recognition is passive. Easy. Comfortable.

    And almost useless for long-term retention.

    Retrieval is different. You must reconstruct the memory from scratch. No cues. No hints. Just your brain searching through networks of associations trying to locate and rebuild the information.

    This reconstruction requires effort. Real cognitive work. And that effort is what strengthens the neural pathway. Each successful retrieval makes the next one easier. The memory becomes more accessible (Bjork, 1994).

    Think of it like a trail through woods. Walking the same cleared path repeatedly keeps it maintained. But bushwhacking through overgrowth to find the trailhead? That’s retrieval. It’s harder. You might get lost. But when you succeed, you’ve created a clearer, more distinct path.

    The difficulty is the mechanism. No struggle, no strengthening.

    You Activate More Than You Retrieve

    Here’s where it gets fascinating.

    When you struggle to retrieve information, you don’t just strengthen the direct memory. You activate related information through spreading activation in semantic memory (Carpenter, 2009, 2011).

    Imagine you’re trying to remember your company’s incident reporting procedure. As you struggle to recall “Document the incident immediately,” your brain activates related concepts: “Notify supervisor,” “Preserve evidence,” “Photos if possible,” “Follow up within 24 hours.”

    These related concepts become linked to your target memory. They create multiple routes to the same destination.

    Carpenter (2011) demonstrated this with word pairs. When learners retrieved weakly associated pairs like “basket” and “bread,” they spontaneously activated semantic mediators—related concepts like “grocery” or “bakery.” These mediators later served as additional retrieval cues. Restudying didn’t produce this effect.

    For workplace application, this is critical. Real problems don’t arrive with helpful labels. Your employees won’t see a notification saying “Time to use your de-escalation training!” They need to access that knowledge spontaneously when a customer starts yelling.

    Multiple access routes make spontaneous recall possible.

    You Learn What You Actually Know

    When Sarah’s employees restudied her harassment prevention slides, everything looked familiar. They thought they knew it. Familiarity felt like learning.

    It wasn’t.

    Retrieval reveals the truth. It exposes the gap between what you think you know and what you can actually recall. This is a metacognitive benefit—your ability to judge your own knowledge (Bjork, 1994).

    Karpicke et al. (2009) studied how college students prepare for exams. The results were striking:

    – 84% relied primarily on rereading

    – Only 1% used self-testing as their main strategy

    When asked why, students said rereading “felt more productive.” But their predictions about their own learning were systematically wrong. Students thought repeated studying would help. Testing actually helped more.

    This is the illusion that sabotages most training. Rereading feels smooth and confident. Testing feels choppy and uncertain. But feelings deceive. The uncertainty during retrieval is a signal of learning, not failure.

    Sarah’s employees felt confident after reviewing her slides. They were wrong. The quiz after training measured recognition—can you identify the right answer when you see it?—not retrieval. Recognition and retrieval are different animals. One works on the job. One doesn’t.

    The Resistance You’ll Face (And Why It Matters)

    Here’s the problem Sarah discovered when she redesigned her training: retrieval practice feels wrong to learners.

    She sent her first spaced quiz one week after training. Simple questions. No tricks. Just “From memory, list three behaviors that constitute reportable harassment under company policy.”

    The responses she got weren’t quiz answers. They were complaints.

    “I don’t remember this. Can you send the slides again?”  

    “This feels like a test. I thought we already passed the training.”  

    “Why are you testing us? Don’t you trust us?”

    Sarah had anticipated resistance. She hadn’t anticipated how visceral it would be.

    But the research predicted this reaction perfectly. When Karpicke et al. (2009) surveyed students about study strategies, they found learners overwhelmingly prefer rereading because it feels productive. It’s smooth. Information flows easily. Learners mistake this fluency for learning.

    Testing feels terrible. You get stuck. You blank on answers you “knew” five minutes ago. You feel uncertain. Learners interpret this difficulty as failure.

    But that difficulty is the entire point.

    Bjork (1994) calls this “desirable difficulty”—obstacles that impair performance during practice but enhance long-term retention. The struggle to retrieve is what makes retrieval practice work.

    This creates a massive challenge for L&D professionals. Your learners will actively resist the strategy that helps them most. They’ll gravitate toward strategies that feel productive but accomplish little.

    Sarah learned to reframe retrieval practice. Not as testing. As a workout for memory. Nobody expects exercise to feel effortless. The challenge is the mechanism of growth.

    She told her team: “If this feels hard, that’s good. If you’re struggling to remember, that’s the point. Your brain is working. That work is what makes knowledge stick.”

    Some grumbled. But after two months, something shifted. Employees started noticing they could answer questions without looking things up. The knowledge was just… there.

    One employee told Sarah: “I hated those pop quizzes at first. But now, when a situation comes up, I actually remember the policy. I don’t have to search for it.”

    That’s when Sarah knew it was working.

    How to Actually Do This: Two Detailed Applications

    Enough theory. Let’s walk through exactly how Sarah implemented retrieval practice—first in her compliance training, then in her technical skills program.

    Application 1: Compliance Training That Actually Sticks

    What Sarah Changed

    Her old approach was typical: 45-minute module, information-dense slides, final quiz with answers visible on the screen above the questions. Pass rate: 95%. Retention three months later: maybe 30%.

    Her new approach eliminated the end-of-training quiz entirely. Instead:

    Day 1 (during training session, last 15 minutes):

    Sarah presented core policy information in 30 minutes instead of 45. Then she closed the slides.

    “Put away your notes. Close the handout. For the next 10 minutes, write everything you remember about what constitutes reportable harassment under our policy.”

    Silence. Discomfort. People looked around nervously.

    “No looking back,” Sarah said. “This isn’t graded. Just write what you remember.”

    People struggled. They wrote a few things, crossed them out, wrote more. After 10 minutes, Sarah gave them a one-page reference sheet showing the actual policy elements.

    “Compare what you wrote to this. Notice what you got right. Notice what you missed. That’s your learning.”

    Week 2 (5 minutes via email):

    Sarah sent a scenario:

    “You witness a colleague make an ambiguous comment to another employee. The recipient looks uncomfortable but doesn’t say anything. Is this reportable under company policy? What’s your next step? Reply with your answer.”

    After people responded, she sent the correct answer with a brief explanation. No scoring. No judgment. Just feedback.

    Month 2 (10 minutes in team meeting):

    Sarah presented a realistic case study. Pairs worked together: one person explained the policy, the other identified gaps or errors, then they switched roles.

    Month 3 (5 minutes via Slack):

    “Real situation from this week: [describes actual ambiguous incident]. How does this relate to our harassment policy?”

    Sarah’s Results

    Three months after training, she ran an unannounced quiz using realistic scenarios. Retention: 78%. Nearly three times better than her previous approach.

    More importantly: when actual incidents occurred, employees actually reported them. They recognized the behavior. They knew the procedure. The knowledge was accessible when they needed it.

    Implementation Details Sarah Learned:

    The free-recall brain dump (Day 1) was crucial. It revealed gaps immediately while the information was fresh enough to correct. But it required Sarah to create a clear reference sheet for self-comparison. Without that, learners felt lost.

    The spaced quizzes (Week 2, Month 2, Month 3) worked best when they pulled from all previous content, not just recent material. This prevented learners from forgetting early content while learning later content.

    Email delivery worked fine for simple questions. For complex scenarios, team meetings created better engagement because people could discuss answers.

    The biggest challenge was getting managers to protect the 5-10 minutes required for retrieval activities. Sarah had to show retention data to prove the time was worth it.

    Application 2: Technical Skills Training (CRM System)

    What Sarah’s Colleague Marcus Changed

    Marcus ran software training for their sales team. His old approach: a full-day session where he demonstrated features while learners followed along. “Sandbox environment available for practice.” About 20% actually used it. Within the first month, 60% called the helpdesk for procedures they should have remembered.

    His new approach split the training across two weeks with retrieval built in:

    Session 1 (2 hours):

    Marcus demonstrated core workflows:

    – Creating a contact (10 minutes demo)

    – Logging a call (10 minutes demo)

    – Creating an opportunity (10 minutes demo)

    Then he closed his screen. “Now you try—from memory. Create a contact using your own information. I’m not showing you the steps. Pull from what you just saw.”

    People fumbled. Clicked the wrong buttons. Got lost. Marcus circulated to help but didn’t re-demonstrate. He prompted: “What did you see me do? What was the first step?”

    This immediate retrieval after each demo took 30 minutes total. Messy. Inefficient. Effective.

    Week 1 (5 minutes each morning):

    Marcus sent daily retrieval prompts:

    Monday: “Don’t open the CRM yet. Write down the steps to create a contact.”  

    Tuesday: “Write the steps to log a call.”  

    Wednesday: “Write the steps to create an opportunity.”  

    Thursday: “Now combine them: Write the full workflow from new contact to logged opportunity.”  

    Friday: “Scenario: Client calls with interest in Product X. Write your complete CRM workflow.”

    After each prompt, people opened the CRM and tried the procedure. They compared what they wrote to what they actually had to do.

    Week 2 (Session 2, 90 minutes):

    Marcus presented progressively harder scenarios. Each one required retrieving earlier knowledge:

    “Client wants Product X but has budget concerns. Create the contact, log this call, create an opportunity with notes about the budget issue.”

    People worked from memory. Real client data. Real consequences for errors. Marcus provided help only for genuine system bugs, not forgotten procedures.

    Marcus’s Results

    Within two weeks, 80% of the sales team was independently proficient. Previously this took two months. Helpdesk calls for “how do I…” questions dropped by 70%.

    Sales reps could execute workflows without references. When weird edge cases appeared, they could figure them out because they understood the logic, not just the steps.

    Implementation Details Marcus Learned:

    The immediate retrieval after each demo (Session 1) was the most important intervention. It revealed mistakes while Marcus was there to help. Waiting until later would have let errors solidify.

    The daily prompts required only 5 minutes but had to be consistent. Missing a day broke the spacing pattern. Marcus automated them using email scheduling.

    The hardest part was resisting the urge to re-demonstrate when people struggled. His instinct was to jump in and show them again. But making them figure it out—with prompts, not answers—was what made knowledge stick.

    Marcus learned to use two-part questions: “Write the steps” (retrieval) then “Now try it” (practice). The retrieval before practice was what made practice effective.

    The Other Applications: Quick Hits

    Product knowledge for customer service: Daily “customer question of the day” sent via Slack. Reps answer from memory. Correct answer shared after responses come in. Three months: customer satisfaction scores up 12% because reps can answer questions without putting customers on hold.

    New hire onboarding: Weekly “teach-back” sessions where new hires explain company procedures to each other. Manager observes, corrects errors. Time to productivity: down 18 days compared to traditional onboarding.

    The pattern is consistent. Replace review with retrieval. Space it out. Make it effortful. Measure retention, not completion.

    The Bottom Line: What Changes in Your Training

    Most organizations build training like this:

    1. Deliver information

    2. Check understanding with a quiz

    3. Issue certificate

    4. Hope learners remember

    Sarah learned to flip this completely:

    1. Deliver information (briefly)

    2. Force immediate retrieval

    3. Space retrieval over weeks

    4. Measure actual retention weeks later

    The shift is from “Did they complete it?” to “Can they recall it without help?”

    This requires three fundamental changes in how you design training:

    First, measure retention, not completion.

    Stop celebrating 95% completion rates. Start measuring what learners remember two weeks, four weeks, and three months after training. Use unannounced quizzes with realistic scenarios. If completion is high but retention is low, your training failed.

    Sarah now tracks two metrics: immediate quiz scores (which she expects to be high) and delayed retention scores (which reveal actual learning). Only the second metric matters for program success.

    Second, replace every review session with retrieval.

    Every time you’re tempted to “review the key points,” stop. Instead, ask learners to retrieve the key points from memory. No slides. No handouts. Just retrieval. Then show them what they missed.

    Sarah eliminated all her “refresher” training. She replaced it with spaced quizzes that force retrieval of previous content. The time commitment is 20% of what refreshers required. The retention is 3x better.

    Third, embrace forgetting as a feature.

    The forgetting curve is your friend. Let learners forget a little between retrieval sessions. When they struggle to remember, that difficulty strengthens the memory.

    Sarah spaces her quizzes strategically: 1 day, 1 week, 1 month, 3 months. Each retrieval resets the forgetting curve at a higher baseline. After four retrievals, knowledge sticks for 6+ months without additional intervention.

    Your Checklist for the Next Training Program

    You’re designing new training. Here’s what changes:

    During Design:

    – Cut your presentation time by 30%. Use that time for retrieval instead.

    – Write 20-30 retrieval questions spanning simple recall to complex application.

    – Schedule retrieval sessions at 1 day, 1 week, 1 month, 3 months.

    – Choose question formats: free recall for complex concepts, short answer for procedures, multiple choice only when you need to scale beyond what you can manually review.

    – Plan feedback: immediate for high-stakes content (safety, compliance), delayed by one day for everything else.

    During Rollout:

    – Tell learners why you’re doing this: “This will feel hard. That means it’s working. The struggle is what makes knowledge stick.”

    – Make first retrieval happen immediately after initial training, before learners leave.

    – Monitor completion of spaced retrieval, not just initial training. If people skip the spaced quizzes, they’ll forget everything.

    – Watch success rates. If below 40%, the questions are too hard. If above 90%, they’re too easy. Target 60-75% success.

    During Measurement:

    – Test retention at 2-4 weeks with unannounced quiz.

    – Compare to previous version of same training (or to control group).

    – Measure on-the-job application through manager observation or real performance data.

    – Calculate time-to-proficiency versus your baseline.

    During Iteration:

    – Identify which specific content is forgotten most often.

    – Add extra retrieval practice for those trouble spots.

    – Experiment with spacing intervals (some content needs more frequent retrieval).

    – Test different question formats to find what works for different content types.

    Sarah now designs all training this way. Her programs take less time to deliver. They cost less to maintain. And they produce dramatically better retention.

    Her secret? She makes learning uncomfortable. And she’s stopped apologizing for it.

    The Uncomfortable Truth

    Retrieval practice works. The evidence is overwhelming. Hundreds of studies. Multiple meta-analyses. Consistent effects across ages, materials, and contexts.

    But it requires you to do something that feels wrong: make learning harder.

    Your instinct is to make training smooth, easy, comfortable. Clear slides. Engaging videos. Lots of review. Retrieval practice is choppy, difficult, frustrating. Learners struggle. They forget. They complain.

    And that’s exactly why it works.

    When Sarah’s employees said “This is hard,” she learned to hear “This is working.” When they said “I don’t remember this,” she learned to hear “My brain is building stronger pathways.” When they complained about “too much testing,” she learned to hear “I’m experiencing desirable difficulty.”

    The struggle is the signal.

    Your job isn’t to make learning feel easy. Your job is to make learning last.

    Sarah learned this when she stopped measuring completion rates and started measuring retention. When she stopped asking “Did they like the training?” and started asking “Can they actually do their jobs better?”

    The answer surprised her. Her new training was less popular in post-training surveys. People complained about the quizzes. They wanted more slides, more review, more support.

    But six months later, when she measured performance, her new approach won decisively. People retained more. They performed better. They needed less remedial training.

    The training that felt worse worked better.

    Sarah now tells new L&D professionals: “If learners say your training is too easy, you’re failing them. If they say it’s too hard, you might be failing them. But if they say it’s challenging but they can feel themselves getting better, you’re doing it right.”

    Retrieval practice is how you do that. It’s how you build knowledge that lasts beyond the training room.

    It’s how you turn completion into competence.

    —

    References

    Adesope, O. O., Trevisan, D. A., & Sundararajan, N. (2017). Rethinking the use of tests: A meta-analysis of practice testing. *Review of Educational Research, 87*(3), 659–701.

    Agarwal, P. K., Nunes, L. D., & Blunt, J. R. (2021). Retrieval practice consistently benefits student learning: A systematic review of applied research in schools and classrooms. *Educational Psychology Review, 33*(4), 1409–1453.

    Bjork, R. A. (1994). Memory and metamemory considerations in the training of human beings. In J. Metcalfe & A. Shimamura (Eds.), *Metacognition: Knowing about knowing* (pp. 185–205). MIT Press.

    Carpenter, S. K. (2009). Cue strength as a moderator of the testing effect: The benefits of elaborative retrieval. *Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 35*(6), 1563–1569.

    Carpenter, S. K. (2011). Semantic information activated during retrieval contributes to later retention: Support for the mediator effectiveness hypothesis of the testing effect. *Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 37*(6), 1547–1552.

    Karpicke, J. D., Butler, A. C., & Roediger, H. L. (2009). Metacognitive strategies in student learning: Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own? *Memory, 17*(4), 471–479.

    Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. *Psychological Science, 17*(3), 249–255.

    Rowland, C. A. (2014). The effect of testing versus restudy on retention: A meta-analytic review of the testing effect. *Psychological Bulletin, 140*(6), 1432–1463.

  • The Dangerous Allure of Distraction: Why Seductive Details Can Derail Learning (and When They Don’t)

    The Dangerous Allure of Distraction: Why Seductive Details Can Derail Learning (and When They Don’t)

    NOTE: I’ve updated this post from the previous version to incorporate some new research shared by Julie Dirksen & Will Thalheimer.

    Every learning designer knows the temptation.

    You’ve built a solid course… but it still feels a little flat.
    So you add a funny story.
    Or a dramatic photo.
    Or a splash of background music because “engagement!”

    And just like that, you’ve stepped into one of the most reliable traps in instructional design: the seductive details effect—where interesting but irrelevant extras quietly pull attention away from the actual thing you need people to learn.

    It’s one of those ideas that sounds small but has outsized consequences. And thanks to decades of research, we now know a lot more about when seductive details hurt learning, why they do it, and the few situations where they’re not as dangerous as they seem.

    Let’s break it down.


    Why Seductive Details Are So… Well, Seductive

    Our brains love novelty. Tiny surprises. Little emotional jolts. Anything that fires up curiosity.

    But in learning, that thrill comes at a cost.

    When you add content that’s fun but not necessary—like a quirky anecdote or a dramatic image—it forces the brain to split attention. Working memory is limited, and every extra bit of processing devoted to something irrelevant is attention not available for the concepts that actually matter.

    And the hit isn’t small.
    Across studies, irrelevant details reduce learning by an average of 15–40%, and the effect is even stronger when visuals and text fight for space on the same screen.

    The punchline:


    What’s New (and Why the Story Isn’t as Simple as “Never Add Anything Fun”)

    Older research painted seductive details as almost always harmful.
    Newer research gives us a more realistic picture.

    Here’s the nuance:

    1. Prior knowledge matters. A lot.

    Novices get derailed easily. Their working memory is already full, so even small distractions knock them off track.

    But experts? They can often handle a decorative detail or two because they already have mental models to fall back on.

    2. Motivation and emotion change the equation.

    Seductive details can boost interest and reduce boredom—especially in long, self-paced programs.

    That emotional lift might help people stick with a course they’d otherwise abandon.

    3. The “dose” and placement make a huge difference.

    A single visual at the periphery? Probably fine.

    A funny sidebar next to a complex diagram? Probably not.

    A story that runs longer than the actual lesson? Definitely not.

    4. The effect is strongest in high-load content.

    If the topic is complex, dense, or unfamiliar, even tiny distractions pull cognitive resources away from meaning-making.

    5. The research you often see quoted comes from very short lessons.

    Most classic seductive-detail studies use 3–5 minute learning segments followed by immediate tests—not the messy, multi-hour reality of workplace learning.

    So: the effect is real, but size and severity vary.


    So When Can You Use Seductive Details Without Wrecking Learning?

    Here’s the short list:

    • When learners already know enough to handle a little extra.
    • When motivation is the bigger barrier than comprehension.
    • When the detail creates emotional connection and you place it away from core content.
    • When the detail helps build a metaphor that actually clarifies meaning.

    Everything else? Probably not worth it.


    What to Do Instead: Design for Cognitive Interest, Not Entertainment

    If you want engagement that builds learning instead of derailing it, focus on what researchers call cognitive interest—the kind of curiosity that points people directly at the idea you want them to understand.

    Here are safer, stronger design moves:

    Use visuals with a job.

    Show relationships. Reduce complexity. Guide the eye.

    Skip the clip art holding a magnifying glass.

    Build relevance, not decoration.

    A scenario that mirrors the real workplace beats a funny aside every time.

    Use contrast and clarity to draw attention.

    People engage longer when content feels simple to navigate and easy to grasp.

    Space key ideas across time.

    Your best “engagement hack” is giving the brain room to breathe.

    If you do add a story, keep it tight and directly connected to the learning point.

    You don’t need a Marvel-level backstory. One crisp, relevant setup is enough.


    The Bottom Line

    Seductive details aren’t evil. They’re just expensive.
    Sometimes the cost is worth paying—most of the time, it isn’t.

    If your goal is learning that sticks, the safest bet is always the same:

    Be intentional.
    Be relevant.
    Make the learning effortless to follow, and every detail earns its place.

    Add delight, not distraction.
    Add meaning, not noise.
    That’s how you design content that respects attention—and actually gets results.

  • Why Harder is Better: The Surprising Science of Desirable Difficulties

    Why Harder is Better: The Surprising Science of Desirable Difficulties

    The training session crushed it. Ninety-four percent completion. Satisfaction scores at 4.8 out of 5. Your VP sent a congratulatory email.

    Three months later? Those same learners failed the audit. Couldn’t recall key steps. Couldn’t apply the principles they’d supposedly mastered.

    What happened?

    You fell into what cognitive scientist Robert Bjork calls the fluency trap. When learning feels smooth and effortless, it tricks everyone—trainers and learners alike—into believing real learning has occurred. The sensation of easy comprehension becomes a false signal. We mistake fluency for mastery.

    We don’t just misread our learners. We misread ourselves.

    The Problem With Smooth

    For decades, L&D has optimized for one thing: comfort. Friction-free slides. Tidy sequences. Clear examples. Remove all obstacles. Make everything easy.

    But here’s what the research keeps proving: Learning that feels easy tends to evaporate fast.

    Bjork and his colleague Elizabeth Bjork spent decades studying this paradox. They discovered what they call “desirable difficulties”—specific challenges that make learning feel harder during training but dramatically improve retention and transfer afterward.

    The term is precise. Not random obstacles. Not confusion or poor design—that’s undesirable difficulty. These are deliberate conditions that require learners to work just hard enough to deepen memory traces.

    Think about the brain-muscle comparison you’ve probably heard. It’s useful shorthand, but the mechanisms work differently than simple resistance training. Neural strength doesn’t come from “resistance” the way muscles do. It comes from retrieval, reconsolidation, and re-encoding. Every time you force your brain to reconstruct knowledge from memory rather than simply recognize it, you strengthen the neural pathways. That effortful reconstruction is what builds durable learning.

    Why Effort Builds Memory

    When information flows too easily, your brain marks it as obvious. Disposable. “This is simple,” your working memory signals. “I won’t need to hang onto this long.”

    But when retrieval or problem-solving takes real effort? Your brain flags that knowledge as important. That struggle triggers deeper encoding through what researchers call levels of processing. The harder your brain works to access information, the stronger the memory trace becomes.

    Research from the testing effect studies proves this consistently. Learners who engage in effortful retrieval—even when they struggle initially—outperform their peers on every durable metric. Retention. Transfer. Novel problem-solving. The works.

    The catch? They feel less confident during training. That’s the trap talking.

    What Desirable Difficulty Looks Like

    Let’s get concrete with two workplace scenarios.

    Sales Training Showdown

    Smooth Approach: Each day covers a single topic. Product features Monday. Objection handling Tuesday. Closing techniques Wednesday. Learners master one thing at a time, advance with confidence, leave feeling competent.

    Feedback forms glow.

    Strategic Difficulty: Mix everything from day one. Simulate real sales calls where features, objections, and closing blend unpredictably. Learners attempt tasks before you’ve finished teaching them. They fail. They wait a few days. They try again.

    This feels messier. Harder. Less organized.

    But field studies on interleaved practice show sales teams trained this way outperform traditional training by 20-25% on transfer tasks. They handle situations they’ve never encountered. The smooth-training group struggles when anything deviates from the script.

    Software Training Reality Check

    Smooth Approach: Polished screencasts. Expert demonstrations. Perfect walkthroughs. Learners follow along step by step. Easy to watch.

    Easy to forget.

    Strategic Difficulty: Start with a problem. “Here’s a business challenge. Solve it using the software.” No walkthrough. No guide. Just coaching.

    Learners experiment. Make mistakes. Ask questions. Figure it out. You reveal job aids after they’ve wrestled with the problem.

    This triggers what’s called the generation effect. When learners generate knowledge before receiving feedback—rather than just consuming pre-packaged information—retention shoots up. They’re not passengers. They’re drivers.

    Eight weeks later, they’re solving novel problems independently while the screencast group keeps calling for support.

    Four Techniques That Build Productive Struggle

    Ready to redesign for retention? Start here.

    1. Force Retrieval, Not Review

    Recognition isn’t recall. When learners review notes, they recognize information: “Oh yeah, I’ve seen this before.” That recognition feels like learning. It isn’t.

    Real learning happens when you close the notes and pull information from memory. When your brain has to reconstruct knowledge rather than simply recognize it. Testing knowledge before teaching it strengthens memory through what’s known as the pre-testing effect.

    Try this: Begin modules with questions learners can’t yet answer. Let them struggle. Then reveal the answers. Studies show this alone can raise retention by roughly 30%.

    The discomfort is the mechanism.

    2. Mix Your Practice (Interleaving)

    Grouping practice by topic feels tidy. Monday we practice scheduling. Tuesday we practice budgeting. Wednesday we practice risk assessment.

    But this blocked practice hinders a critical skill: discrimination. When learners know in advance which tool they’ll need, they never learn to diagnose which situation calls for which solution.

    Mixing related tasks forces learners to constantly decide which rule or skill fits each problem. That discrimination—figuring out what type of problem you’re facing—strengthens learning dramatically.

    Try this: Combine scheduling, budgeting, and risk scenarios in unpredictable order. Every session should require all three skills mixed together. Just like real work.

    3. Space Learning Over Time

    Marathon workshops feel efficient. Get everyone in a room. Cover everything. Done.

    Except it doesn’t work.

    The spacing effect—one of the most robust findings in cognitive science—shows that distributed practice outperforms massed sessions every time. The mechanism isn’t about preventing forgetting. It’s about leveraging partial forgetting. When learners return after a delay, they’ve lost some information. Retrieving it takes effort. That effortful retrieval after partial forgetting builds more durable memory than continuous exposure ever could.

    Try this: Replace your next eight-hour workshop with four two-hour sessions across four weeks. Watch retention scores climb.

    4. Vary Your Examples Wildly

    Using the same polished example repeatedly feels clear and consistent. But it builds narrow understanding.

    When you show a concept working in radically different contexts, learners have to extract the underlying principle that works across situations. That extraction builds flexible schemas—mental models that transfer.

    Teaching “clear communication”? Don’t show three email examples. Show clear communication in an email, a difficult conversation, a presentation, and a technical document. Force learners to figure out what makes communication clear regardless of medium.

    Try this: For every principle, prepare three examples from completely different domains. Ask learners to explain how the same concept applies to each. That explanation strengthens their mental model.

    The Satisfaction Score Trap

    Here’s where you need courage.

    Training that incorporates desirable difficulties often earns lower immediate satisfaction ratings. Learners don’t enjoy struggle. It feels harder. Less comfortable. It doesn’t produce that immediate “I’ve got this!” sensation.

    And here’s the uncomfortable truth: Satisfaction scores don’t predict performance. In fact, research on metacognitive accuracy shows that confidence and actual competence often correlate negatively. The most confident learners sometimes learned the least.

    So what should you measure?

    • Retention at 30, 60, 90 days
    • Transfer to novel contexts
    • Performance under pressure
    • On-the-job application

    These metrics reveal whether training works. Satisfaction scores reveal whether it felt good. Sometimes you get both. Often you don’t.

    Choose effectiveness.

    Making the Shift

    If you’ve spent years optimizing for ease, this requires a philosophical change. Here’s your roadmap.

    Audit for over-smoothness. Look at your last course. Where did you make things too easy? Where could learners retrieve instead of review? Where did you organize practice too neatly?

    Educate stakeholders early. Share this research before launch. Help leaders understand why short-term discomfort produces long-term results. Get buy-in for training that feels different.

    Start small. Don’t overhaul everything at once. Add one desirable difficulty—retrieval practice, spacing, or variation—to your next project. Build confidence through experience.

    Distinguish difficulty from confusion. This is critical. Not all difficulty is desirable. Confusing instructions aren’t productive struggle. Unclear objectives aren’t strategic challenge. Poor design isn’t cognitive load—or rather, it’s the wrong kind. Cognitive load that aids learning helps learners process and integrate information. Overload or unclear design just overwhelms. Know the difference.

    The Choice You’re Already Making

    Every time you design a learning experience, you’re making a choice—whether you realize it or not.

    Do you want learners to feel confident today, or be competent three months from now?

    You can optimize for comfort during training and watch everything evaporate within weeks. Or you can introduce strategic struggle during training and build capability that lasts for months.

    Most organizations chase high satisfaction scores and smooth delivery without realizing they’re sacrificing actual learning. They wonder why training doesn’t transfer. Why performance doesn’t improve. Why they keep retraining the same content.

    You now know why.

    Desirable difficulties aren’t about making training arbitrarily hard. They’re about targeted challenge that strengthens memory. Strategic friction that builds capability. Productive struggle that produces lasting results.

    Your learners might not thank you immediately. But three months later, when they’re the only ones who remember what they learned? When they’re solving problems their peers can’t touch? When they’re applying principles in situations you never trained them for?

    That’s when the choice you made will prove itself.

    This is the first in a series on foundational learning research. Each principle will challenge conventional L&D wisdom. Each will give you evidence-based tools to design training that actually works.

    The question isn’t whether you’ll face this choice.

    You’re facing it right now with your next course.

    Choose wisely.


    Key Research

    Core Concept:

    • Bjork, R. A. (1994). Memory and metamemory considerations in the training of human beings. In J. Metcalfe & A. Shimamura (Eds.), Metacognition: Knowing about knowing. MIT Press.
    • Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society. Worth Publishers.
    • Bjork, R. A., & Bjork, E. L. (2020). Desirable difficulties in theory and practice. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 9(4), 475-479.

    Supporting Evidence:

    • Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). The testing effect. Psychological Science, 17(3).
    • Rohrer, D., & Taylor, K. (2007). The shuffling of mathematics problems improves learning. Instructional Science, 35(6).
    • Cepeda, N. J., et al. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3).