Category: Instructional Design

  • Stop Building Training That Was Never Going to Work

    Stop Building Training That Was Never Going to Work

    A free tool that walks you and your stakeholders through Mager and Pipe’s performance flowchart, before anyone opens an authoring tool.

    Here’s a made-up request. You’ve seen one like it.

    An ops manager emails: “My reps keep skipping call notes in the CRM. Can you build a refresher course?”

    So you ask a few questions. The reps know the standard. It’s in the handbook. They covered it in onboarding. But the note field sits three screens deep. They get about ten seconds between calls. And the only number anyone tracks is handle time, so every note they write makes them look slower.

    Now, picture the refresher course. It’s well designed. Reps pass the quiz. Then they go back to the same screens, the same ten seconds, and the same scorecard.

    Nothing changes. Nothing could have.

    Training fixes one thing

    Training helps people who don’t know how to do something. That’s it.

    If people already know how, a course can’t help. Maybe the right way is slow. Maybe the wrong way pays off. Maybe nobody notices either way. In every one of those cases, training has zero chance of working.

    Yet it’s still the default answer. It’s visible. It’s easy to order. It looks like action. The real fixes, like clear expectations, better tools, honest feedback, and incentives that make sense, never come up. Nobody asks the questions that would surface them.

    So I built a tool that asks them for you.

    Meet the Performance Problem Navigator

    The Performance Problem Navigator is a free, interactive version of Mager and Pipe’s performance analysis flowchart. Open it with your stakeholder. Answer one question at a time. By the end, you’ll know whether training can fix the problem, and what to do if it can’t.

    Try the Performance Problem Navigator

    Training is the last box on the chart

    Robert Mager and Peter Pipe first published Analyzing Performance Problems in 1970. The Navigator follows the flowchart from the 1997 edition. It moves through six questions, in order:

    1. What’s the problem? What’s happening, and what should be?
    2. Is it worth solving? Some problems cost less to live with than to fix.
    3. Can we apply fast fixes? Clear expectations, enough resources, visible results.
    4. Are consequences appropriate? Is the right way punished, or the wrong way rewarded?
    5. Do they already know how? Is there a real skill gap?
    6. Are there more clues? Can the task be easier? What else is in the way?

    Look where training lands. It’s the very last box. Fifteen decisions come first. That order is the lesson.

    What you get that a paper chart can’t give you

    A chart on the wall doesn’t run the meeting. The Navigator does.

    • Your stakeholder can follow along. Every question is in plain English, with the original chart step named underneath.
    • You’ll never stall. Each step gives you questions to ask out loud.
    • Nothing gets lost. You capture evidence as you go, in their words.
    • “I don’t know” won’t derail you. “Not sure” is an answer. It gets flagged as an open question instead of a guess.
    • You walk out with something to send. The summary gives a bottom line on training, the fixes found, open questions, and an action plan. Copy it into an email.

    The hardest conversation gets easier

    That summary is the part I care about most.

    Telling someone “training won’t fix this” is one of the toughest moments in L&D. They asked for a course. You’re saying no. It can feel like you’re refusing to help.

    The summary changes that. You’re not giving your opinion. You’re handing back their own answers, in order, with the fixes they point to. It’s hard to argue with what you just said yourself.

    The one question that matters most

    If you remember one step, make it this one: do they really lack the skill?

    Mager and Pipe’s test is simple. If their job depended on it, could they do it right now? If yes, it’s not a training problem. Full stop.

    Try it on your next request

    Pick the next training request that lands in your inbox. Before you open your authoring tool, open the Navigator.

    If the answer is training, great. Now you know it can work. If it isn’t, you may have just saved weeks building something that never stood a chance.

  • 10 Popular L&D Ideas Worth Revisiting

    10 Popular L&D Ideas Worth Revisiting

    Recently, I read The Untold Story of Bloom’s Taxonomy by Carl Hendrick.

    That name instantly took me back.

    Like many people in Learning and Development, I was introduced to Bloom’s years ago. I’ve seen it referenced in conference presentations, certification programs, instructional design books, and countless conversations about learning objectives. But as I read the article, I realized something uncomfortable: much of what I thought I knew about Bloom didn’t come from Bloom.

    It came from pyramids, templates, conference talks, and other people who had learned it the same way.

    That made me wonder:

    How many L&D “facts” are actually simplified versions of the original idea?

    This isn’t an attempt to tear down the profession’s favorite models. Most became popular because they’re useful. But useful isn’t the same as proven, and a model isn’t a law.

    Ideas also change as they travel. Someone trims a complex concept for a workshop. Someone else turns it into a graphic. A catchy statistic gets added. Eventually, the simplified version becomes easier to remember than the source.

    And that’s when things get interesting.

    The goal isn’t to debunk these ideas. It’s to revisit them. Some turn out to be myths. Some are good models that have been stretched beyond their original purpose. Others work quite well, but only under the right conditions.

    Here are ten L&D ideas that became simpler, more certain, and sometimes less accurate as they traveled.


    1. People Learn Best in Their Learning Style

    Verdict: 🚫 Myth

    Visual learners need pictures. Auditory learners need sound. Kinesthetic learners need hands-on practice.

    It has a nice ring to it. It also feels respectful. People are different, so surely we should teach each person in the way they prefer.

    The first part is true. People do have preferences. The second part is where the evidence weakens.

    There has been a lot of research on whether matching instruction to a learner’s preferred style improves outcomes. All of them concluded there was not an adequate evidence base for using learning-style assessments in general educational practice.

    That doesn’t mean visuals are bad or hands-on practice has no value. The best format often depends on the content. A map helps people navigate. Audio helps with pronunciation. Physical practice helps when learning a physical skill.

    The content should guide the method, not a label attached to the learner.

    Takeaway: Preferences are real. The evidence supporting instruction matched to individual learning styles is much weaker than many people assume.

    Sources

    • Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., and Bjork, R. (2009). Learning Styles: Concepts and Evidence.
    • Coffield, F., Moseley, D., Hall, E., and Ecclestone, K. (2004). Learning Styles and Pedagogy in Post-16 Learning.

    2. 70-20-10 Is a Proven Formula

    Verdict: ⚠️ Useful Idea, Weak Evidence

    You probably know the numbers:

    • 70% from experience
    • 20% from other people
    • 10% from formal learning

    They’re easy to remember, which may explain why so many people started treating them as a formula rather than an observation.

    The model grew from reports about how successful managers believed they had developed during their careers. It wasn’t a controlled experiment proving that everyone learns in those exact ratios.

    Researcher Alan Clardy reviewed the evidence and argued that support for the specific percentages was far weaker than many practitioners assume.

    None of that makes workplace experience unimportant. People clearly learn through assignments, coaching, observation, feedback, and mistakes. The issue is that an observation gradually became a prescription. Somewhere along the way, a useful reminder to look beyond formal training started being treated like a universal rule.

    Takeaway: Use 70-20-10 as a prompt to think broadly about development, not as arithmetic you must obey.

    Sources

    • Lombardo, M., and Eichinger, R. (1996). The Career Architect Development Planner.
    • Clardy, A. (2018). 70-20-10 and the Dominance of Informal Learning: A Fact in Search of Evidence.

    3. Bloom’s Taxonomy Is a Staircase

    Verdict: ⚠️ Useful Model, Often Misapplied

    Most of us know Bloom’s as six levels stacked in a pyramid:

    Remember. Understand. Apply. Analyze. Evaluate. Create.

    That image encourages a tidy story. Start at the bottom, move upward, and aim for the top because creating is always best.

    The real story is more nuanced.

    Bloom’s original taxonomy was designed to classify educational objectives and create a shared language for discussing them. It included a hierarchy, but it wasn’t intended as a universal instructional process that every lesson must follow.

    Creating isn’t automatically the right goal. If I’m learning an emergency procedure, accurate recall may matter far more than producing something new. Experts also move back and forth among different types of thinking rather than climbing a ladder one rung at a time.

    Takeaway: Bloom’s can help align goals, instruction, and assessment. It shouldn’t dictate a rigid sequence for every learning experience.

    Sources

    • Bloom, B. (1956). Taxonomy of Educational Objectives.
    • Anderson, L., and Krathwohl, D. (2001). A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing.
    • Hendrick, C. The Untold Story of Bloom’s Taxonomy.

    4. People Remember 90 Percent of What They Do

    Verdict: 🚫 Myth

    You’ve probably seen the graphic.

    People remember:

    • 10% of what they read
    • 20% of what they hear
    • 90% of what they do

    Those numbers are frequently connected to Edgar Dale’s Cone of Experience.

    Perhaps the most surprising part of the famous retention chart is that the percentages most people remember never appeared in Dale’s original work.

    His cone described different types of learning experiences ranging from more concrete to more abstract. The retention statistics appeared later and have no clear research foundation.

    That doesn’t mean practice is ineffective. Practice can be incredibly valuable. But retention depends on many factors, including prior knowledge, attention, retrieval, feedback, spacing, and context. No honest chart can reduce all of that complexity to three neat percentages.

    Takeaway: Learning by doing can be powerful. The famous retention numbers are not supported by strong evidence.

    Sources

    • Dale, E. (1946). Audio-Visual Methods in Teaching.
    • Thalheimer, W. (2006). People Remember 10%, 20%…Oh Really?

    5. People Have an Eight-Second Attention Span

    Verdict: 🚫 Myth

    The story goes like this:

    Human attention spans have shrunk to eight seconds. That’s supposedly shorter than a goldfish.

    Therefore, every learning experience should be tiny.

    It’s a memorable claim. It’s just not a well-supported one.

    While attention is undoubtedly affected by our environment, researchers have struggled to find evidence supporting a universal eight-second human attention span. People still lose themselves in novels, hobbies, games, and multi-hour projects.

    The issue isn’t that humans suddenly forgot how to focus. It’s that attention now competes with more distractions than ever.

    Takeaway: Don’t design around a goldfish statistic. Earn attention through relevance, clarity, challenge, and good pacing.


    6. Adults Learn in a Completely Different Way Than Children

    Verdict: ⚠️ Useful Perspective, Ongoing Debate

    Adult Learning Theory gave L&D an important reminder: adults bring experience, responsibilities, motivations, and a need for relevance.

    The trouble begins when those useful observations become a rigid divide.

    Adults are self-directed. Children are dependent. Adults are internally motivated. Children are externally motivated.

    Real people are messier than that.

    Recent critiques have questioned whether adult and child learning differ as sharply as andragogy is often portrayed. Some scholars argue that while adults and children may learn in different contexts, the underlying mechanisms of learning are often more similar than traditional descriptions suggest.

    That’s not an argument against relevance, autonomy, or experience. It’s a reminder that human learning is usually more complicated than a checklist.

    Takeaway: Design for the people and situation in front of you, not for a simplified description of what all adults supposedly have in common.

    Sources

    • Knowles, M. (1973). The Adult Learner: A Neglected Species.
    • Knowles, M. (1980). The Modern Practice of Adult Education.
    • Moll, I. (2024). A Psychological Critique of Knowles’ Andragogy as a Theory of Learning.

    7. Kirkpatrick Proves the Training Worked

    Verdict: ⚠️ Useful Framework, Often Oversimplified

    The problem with Kirkpatrick isn’t Kirkpatrick. It’s the tidy staircase many of us were taught.

    Too often, the four levels become a checklist: Did people like the training? Did they pass the test? Did their behavior change? Did business results improve?

    That creates a neat story from Reaction to Results. But a neat story is not proof. Each connection still needs evidence.

    The updated model is more connected and iterative than the familiar staircase suggests. It starts with the results an organization needs, works backward to the behaviors that support them, and asks what must happen on the job to sustain those behaviors. Training is only one part of that system.

    So the question isn’t whether Kirkpatrick is right or wrong. It’s whether we use the model to guide better questions or treat it as automatic proof that training caused the result.

    Takeaway: Use Kirkpatrick to build a chain of evidence, not a ladder of assumptions. Start with the result, identify the behavior that could influence it, and test each connection.

    Sources

    • Kirkpatrick, J. D., & Kirkpatrick, W. K. (2016). Kirkpatrick’s Four Levels of Training Evaluation. ATD Press.
    • Cahapay, M. (2021). Kirkpatrick Model: Its Limitations as Used in Higher Education Evaluation.

    8. Engagement Means Learning

    Verdict: ⚠️ Useful Measure, Weak Evidence

    The room was lively. The chat was flying. Learners were clicking, commenting, laughing, and participating.

    Success, right?

    Maybe.

    One of the easiest traps in L&D is confusing evidence of activity with evidence of learning. The two often overlap, but they’re not the same thing.

    Researchers and learning scientists have long argued that learners are not especially good judges of their own learning. In Make It Stick, Brown, Roediger, and McDaniel describe how learners often mistake familiarity, fluency, and enjoyment for durable learning. Techniques that feel easy and engaging can create an illusion of learning, while techniques that feel more difficult may produce stronger long-term retention.

    The same theme appears throughout How Learning Happens by Paul Kirschner and Carl Hendrick. Learning is not always obvious while it’s happening. A learner can feel confident without learning much, and they can feel challenged or uncertain while making significant progress.

    That doesn’t mean engagement is unimportant. Few people learn effectively when they are distracted, confused, or completely disengaged. Attention matters. Motivation matters. Participation matters.

    The problem comes when we stop there.

    A crowded discussion board doesn’t prove understanding. High completion rates don’t prove retention. A great satisfaction score doesn’t prove behavior change or improved performance.

    In other words, engagement may be a useful leading indicator, but it’s a poor substitute for evidence that learning actually occurred.

    Takeaway: Engagement can support learning, but it isn’t learning. Measure attention, participation, and satisfaction if they’re useful. Just don’t mistake them for retention, transfer, or performance improvement.

    Sources

    • Brown, P., Roediger, H., and McDaniel, M. (2014). Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning.
    • Kirschner, P., and Hendrick, C. (2020). How Learning Happens.
    • Clark, R., and Mayer, R. (2023). e-Learning and the Science of Instruction.

    9. Microlearning Is Better

    Verdict: ✅ Context Dependent

    Unlike some items on this list, microlearning has meaningful evidence behind it.

    Recent systematic reviews have reported generally positive outcomes across multiple studies while also noting significant variation in definitions, implementation approaches, and research methods.

    The issue isn’t that microlearning never works. The issue is that “make it shorter” has become an answer before we’ve asked the question.

    A short lesson may be ideal for a refresher, job aid, or narrowly focused task. Building a complex skill is a different challenge entirely. Some capabilities require time, feedback, repetition, coaching, and sustained practice.

    Breaking a weak course into ten shorter pieces doesn’t improve the content. It simply gives you ten smaller pieces of weak content.

    Takeaway: Short is a format, not a strategy. Good design starts with the need.

    Sources

    • Monib, W., Qazi, A., and Apong, R. (2025). Microlearning Beyond Boundaries: A Systematic Review and a Novel Framework for Improving Learning Outcomes.

    10. Gamification Works

    Verdict: ✅ Context Dependent

    Points. Badges. Leaderboards.

    Done, right?

    Not quite.

    Research generally supports the idea that well-designed gamification can improve learning outcomes. However, the size of those effects varies considerably depending on the audience, content, design approach, duration, and learning environment.

    That’s a much more useful conclusion than either extreme: “Gamification works” or “Gamification is a gimmick.”

    A leaderboard may motivate one audience and discourage another. A storyline may add meaning or add noise. A challenge may promote useful practice or reward speed on the wrong task.

    Like most instructional tools, it depends on how it’s used.

    Takeaway: Game elements are ingredients. Their value depends on what you’re trying to make.

    Sources

    • Li, M., Ma, S., and Shi, Y. (2023). Examining the Effectiveness of Gamification as a Tool Promoting Teaching and Learning in Educational Settings: A Meta-Analysis.
    • Kapp, K. (2012). The Gamification of Learning and Instruction.

    The Bigger Lesson

    The point isn’t that L&D has been foolish. It’s that useful ideas change as they travel.

    A model starts with nuance. Someone trims it for a workshop. Someone turns it into a pyramid. A memorable statistic gets attached. Before long, the simplified version becomes easier to remember than the source.

    That’s how a guide becomes a rule, a ratio becomes a law, and a preference becomes a learning need. The transformation happens gradually, usually with good intentions. Each simplification makes the idea easier to teach and remember. Unfortunately, it can also make the idea less accurate.

    We don’t need to throw away every familiar model. We do need to hold them a little more lightly.

    Ask where an idea came from. Check what the original source actually claimed. Look for the limits, not just the headline. Then decide whether the model fits the problem in front of you.

    Models help us think. Problems begin when we stop thinking and let the model do it for us.

    The goal isn’t to collect more frameworks. It’s to stay curious enough to revisit the ones we already know.

    Because in a profession built around learning, some of the most valuable lessons come from what we’re willing to unlearn.

  • When AI Can Make Almost Anything, Judgment Becomes the Job

    When AI Can Make Almost Anything, Judgment Becomes the Job

    AI can now build a decent presentation in less time than it takes to refill your coffee.

    Give it a report, meeting notes, and an old deck you like. A few minutes later, you may have a polished set of slides with charts, colors, layouts, and formatting that look surprisingly good.

    That is impressive. It is also a little distracting.

    I recently watched an episode of Next Slide, Please about new presentation features in Google’s Gemini and Anthropic’s Claude. The hosts showed these tools using existing decks as visual references. The AI did not just grab similar colors. It copied small design choices such as spacing, margins, type styles, and layout patterns.

    The obvious story is that AI is getting better at making slides.

    The more important story is that making slides is becoming less valuable than deciding what belongs on them.

    Production is getting cheap

    For years, many knowledge workers have been judged by what they produce.

    How many courses did you build? How many slides did you create? How many reports, job aids, videos, or campaigns did your team ship?

    Those numbers are easy to see, so they are easy to reward. But they have never been the same as value.

    Now AI is exposing that gap.

    When almost anyone can create ten versions in minutes, the important question is no longer, “Can you make this?”

    It is, “Can you tell me which version is worth using, and why?”

    That is judgment.

    The real work was hiding inside the work

    Most people think building a presentation is about writing slides and arranging objects. Some of it is. But the harder work happens before the final layout.

    You sort through too much information. You decide what the audience needs and what it does not. You test the logic, cut weak points, question assumptions, and choose what deserves attention.

    The deck is the visible artifact. Judgment is the work underneath it.

    The same is true when you design training, write an article, plan a campaign, or recommend a solution. The finished product gets noticed. The choices behind it create the value.

    AI can remove a lot of production work, and I am happy to let it. I have no deep emotional attachment to resizing text boxes.

    But if we hand off the choices too, we are not saving time. We are giving away the part of the job that matters most.

    Polish can hide weak thinking

    This is where things get tricky.

    In the past, messy thinking often produced messy slides. The story wandered. The design felt crowded. The gaps were easier to see.

    AI can now wrap weak thinking in a clean layout.

    A shaky claim can sit beside a polished chart. A shallow analysis can look finished. A recommendation built on thin evidence can arrive with confident headings, tasteful colors, and very tidy margins.

    The better AI gets at presentation, the easier it becomes to confuse polish with quality.

    They are not the same.

    A useful test is to imagine the meeting after the deck is done. Someone asks where a number came from. A leader challenges the recommendation. A subject matter expert points out the exception that changes everything.

    The slides cannot defend the thinking. You have to.

    When content becomes abundant, judgment becomes scarce

    AI is not only changing presentation design. It is changing learning and development, marketing, consulting, research, and nearly every kind of knowledge work.

    Content is becoming abundant. Judgment is not.

    Judgment means weighing the evidence, reading the context, recognizing the tradeoffs, and making a choice you can explain. It requires a different set of questions:

    • Is this the right problem to solve?
    • What evidence supports this conclusion?
    • What assumptions are we making?
    • What might the AI have missed or flattened?
    • Which option best fits this audience and situation?
    • What should happen next?

    AI can generate options. It can summarize the inputs and suggest a path. It may even spot something you missed.

    But it does not know your organization, audience, constraints, and stakes the way you do. More importantly, it cannot own the consequences of the choice.

    That part is still ours.

    This is an opportunity for L&D

    For years, learning professionals have talked about becoming less like order takers and more like performance consultants. AI may force that shift faster than any new model or framework ever did.

    Imagine a leader asks for training because a team keeps missing a step in an important process. AI can draft the course, create a quiz, write a job aid, and produce the launch email before lunch.

    Useful? Absolutely.

    But none of those assets matter if the real problem is a confusing system, a broken process, competing priorities, or a step that should not exist in the first place.

    AI can help us investigate the problem. It can suggest questions, compare possible causes, and organize the evidence. It should not get the final vote.

    That is where learning professionals can bring more value.

    Our best contribution is not the number of courses or slides we produce. It is diagnosing the problem before prescribing training. It is asking better questions, making sense of conflicting signals, earning a stakeholder’s trust, and connecting learning to real performance.

    When production gets cheaper, those skills become easier to see.

    Use AI for leverage, not permission

    I am not arguing that we should slow AI down or cling to every manual task. Quite the opposite.

    Let AI create the first draft. Let it clean up the deck, summarize the research, suggest a structure, and give you options. Then use the saved time to do the work that deserves more attention.

    Before you put your name on the result, ask:

    • Can I explain the reasoning in plain language?
    • Can I trace the important claims back to reliable evidence?
    • Do I understand the tradeoffs?
    • What would make me change my recommendation?
    • Will this help someone make a better decision or improve performance?

    If you cannot answer those questions, the work is not finished, no matter how polished it looks.

    The bottom line

    AI is lowering the cost of creating content. That is useful, exciting, and probably overdue.

    But lower production costs do not remove the need for expertise. They reveal where expertise was hiding all along.

    It was never just in making the thing.

    It was in knowing what to make, what to leave out, what to question, and what to do next.

    When AI can make almost anything, judgment becomes the job.


  • Why We Kept Our Learning Games Out of the LMS

    Why We Kept Our Learning Games Out of the LMS

    This year, we created a series of 90s-themed cybersecurity games to support our annual compliance campaign.

    Designing the games was the fun part.

    Then came the less glamorous question:

    How would we track who completed them?

    The obvious answer was our LMS. It was also a much bigger answer than we needed.

    The Games Expanded the Campaign

    Our employees already had an annual cybersecurity course to complete. The games weren’t meant to replace it. They gave people more ways to notice, explore, and talk about the campaign around it.

    These were short, fun challenges or browser-based games. One took employees through a social engineering scenario. Another turned a password challenge into a character reveal.

    The 90s television theme gave the campaign a personality. Leaderboard points and prize drawings added curiosity and friendly competition.

    This is the approach Bianca Baumann and I advocate in Think Like a Marketer, Train Like an L&D Pro: don’t assume good learning will attract attention on its own.

    Marketers create several ways for people to encounter a product. We wanted to create several ways for employees to encounter cybersecurity.

    The annual course delivered the required learning. The games helped the larger campaign earn attention.

    But every game raised the same tracking question.

    What Did We Actually Need to Know?

    As instructional designers, we’re good at building systems.

    Sometimes a little too good.

    A simple tracking request can quickly grow into conversations about LMS settings, SCORM packages, dashboards, data models, automation, and reporting rules.

    Before building any of that, we stopped and asked:

    What problem are we actually trying to solve?

    We needed to know three things:

    • Who completed each game?
    • Who earned leaderboard points?
    • Who qualified for prize drawings?

    We weren’t issuing certificates. The games weren’t part of anyone’s compliance record. We didn’t need detailed data about every click or choice.

    We just needed to connect a completed game to an employee.

    One Form. One Question.

    Each game ended with a completion result. Depending on the activity, that might be a generated code, secret phrase, puzzle answer, or character name.

    Employees clicked a link and entered that result in a Microsoft Form.

    That was the entire process.

    Because they were already signed in through Microsoft 365, Forms captured their identity and submission details. We didn’t need to ask for a name, email address, employee ID, department, or business unit.

    The form had one question:

    What is your completion code?

    Why We Didn’t Use the LMS

    We could have placed each game in our LMS. That would have provided more formal tracking.

    It also would have created more work on both sides.

    Employees might have needed to open the LMS, locate the right activity, launch it, move through several screens, and confirm completion.

    None of those clicks would have improved the game. They would have created more distance between “That looks fun” and actually playing.

    The LMS would have added work for our team too. Each activity would need to be packaged, uploaded, configured, tested, and maintained.

    Even a small change could become a project. Fixing one instruction might mean editing the source, publishing the package again, replacing it in the LMS, and testing it one more time.

    With Forms, we could update an instruction or code in minutes.

    The LMS wasn’t the wrong tool. It was simply more tool than this job required.

    Friction Works Both Ways

    We often discuss friction as a learner problem. Every field, login, and extra click asks for a little more time and attention.

    But learning teams pay for friction too.

    They pay through added development, more testing, slower updates, and ongoing maintenance.

    That doesn’t mean we should collect no data or avoid robust systems. It means the value of the information should justify the effort required to collect it.

    For required compliance training, detailed records matter.

    For a voluntary game and prize drawing, a one-question form may be enough.

    The tracking method should match the stakes.

    Our System Wasn’t Airtight

    A submitted code showed that an employee had the code. It didn’t prove, beyond all doubt, that the person completed every part of the game.

    Someone could share an answer.

    We accepted that risk because these were optional campaign activities, not certifications or legal records. Making participation easy mattered more than building perfect proof.

    Different stakes would have led to a different decision.

    Simple worked because it was appropriate, not because simple is always better.

    We Added Complexity When It Earned Its Place

    Later, we connected the Forms data to Power Automate. That helped us manage leaderboard points and other campaign features.

    We didn’t reject complexity. We added it when it produced clear value.

    That sequence matters.

    Start with the smallest system that solves the real problem. Then add new parts when you can explain exactly what they improve.

    Otherwise, every new layer becomes something your team has to build, test, maintain, and feed.

    The Bottom Line

    The games helped our cybersecurity campaign earn attention.

    Microsoft Forms lets us track participation without taking that attention away.

    That’s the larger lesson. Treat learning like a product that needs to be marketed. Create reasons for people to notice it, explore it, and talk about it.

    Then choose support systems that fit the purpose and stakes of the experience.

    Nobody talked about our form.

    Nobody talked about the automation.

    Nobody talked about the reporting.

    They talked about the games.

    That was the clearest sign that we had spent our time on the right things.

  • Five Studies That Shaped My Thinking About Training

    Five Studies That Shaped My Thinking About Training

    When training fails, our first instinct is often to add something.

    Another explanation. Another example. Another module. Maybe a quiz with three answers nobody could possibly get wrong.

    But what if content isn’t the problem?

    I recently reviewed 50 studies from psychology, behavioral science, and learning research. I chose them for their influence, historical value, and usefulness at work.

    Several of them highlight that training isn’t always the answer.

    Here are five that changed how I think about performance.

    Get the complete 50-study field guide

    Want the other 45? I compiled all 50 studies, along with their limitations, workplace applications, and practical ideas, into a free field guide.

    ​

    ​

    A layout problem can become a learning problem

    Picture a diagram on one side of a screen and its explanation on the other. Your eyes bounce back and forth. Meanwhile, your brain tries to hold one piece in memory while searching for the next. That mental juggling has a cost. Paul Chandler and John Sweller called it the split-attention effect. When people must combine related information from different places, the layout itself can interfere with learning.

    Split attention—and related attention problems—can appear when we:

    • Put a legend far from the visual it explains
    • Separate instructions from the task
    • Make employees switch between systems to assemble one answer
    • Show visuals that compete with the narration
    • Add decoration that steals attention

    The lesson is not “make everything shorter.” It is this:

    Make important relationships easier to see.

    Try this: Find one screen that separates information people must understand together. Put those pieces side by side—but don’t duplicate information that already makes sense on its own. ​

    ​

    Remembering beats reviewing

    Rereading feels productive.

    The words look familiar. The page makes sense. We nod along and mistake recognition for mastery.

    Then we need the information three days later—and it has vanished.

    Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke compared repeated study with retrieval practice: asking people to recall what they had learned.

    Repeated study performed better after a very short delay. Retrieval produced stronger retention later.

    That difference matters.

    If people need knowledge on the job, they should practice retrieving it from memory—not merely looking it up again.

    A quiz should not be the inspection station at the end of a course. Used well, it can help create the learning.

    Try this: Before reviewing something you have already taught, ask learners to recall it without looking. Then provide the correct answer and useful feedback.

    Effort helps when success is possible and feedback follows. Blind frustration does not.


    Impact becomes real when it has a face

    Organizational psychologist Adam Grant and his colleagues studied university fundraising callers.

    Some callers met a scholarship student whose education had been funded by their work.

    The script stayed the same. So did the pay.

    But the callers could now picture someone who benefited when they picked up the phone. After meeting the student, they worked longer and raised more money.

    Now compare that with the language we often use to introduce workplace training:

    • Maintain compliance
    • Reduce organizational risk
    • Support strategic priorities
    • Complete this requirement by Friday

    Technically accurate. Emotionally dead.

    Grant studied direct contact with a beneficiary, not whether a good story can rescue a dull compliance course. But the design question travels well:

    Can employees see the person their actions affect?

    Who stays safe? Whose work becomes easier?

    Try this: Replace “This training is important because…” with a real example of someone affected by the behavior.

    Don’t just explain the requirement. Give the consequence a face.


    Information cannot fix a friction problem

    Imagine you know exactly what to do.

    Then you meet the form.

    The instructions are vague. The button you need is buried three menus deep. One approval takes four days, and nobody knows who owns it.

    Would another course help?

    Eric Bettinger and his colleagues studied families applying for college financial aid. One group received personalized information. Another received the same information, plus hands-on help completing and submitting the application.

    The help changed behavior. Information alone did much less.

    The workplace parallel is hard to miss. We prescribe training when the real obstacle is:

    • A confusing form
    • A buried button
    • Too many approvals
    • An unclear process
    • A lack of time
    • A system designed like an escape room

    If people already know what to do, more content is unlikely to save the day.

    Try this: Before building training, watch someone perform the task. Count the clicks, decisions, delays, handoffs, and chances to give up.

    You may not have a knowledge problem. You may have a friction problem.

    Sometimes the right intervention is not better instruction. It is fixing the system.


    A badly framed norm can make behavior worse

    In a well-known field experiment, households learned how their energy use compared with their neighbors’.

    The heavy users cut back.

    But some households that had used less energy began using more. Once they saw the average, they drifted toward it even though that meant doing worse.

    A small sign of approval, a smiley face, stopped that boomerang effect.

    Now consider this workplace message:

    Thirty percent of employees still click suspicious links.

    The intended message is clear:

    This behavior needs to change.

    But employees may hear something else:

    Plenty of people do it. I wouldn’t be unusual.

    Never make the behavior you want to stop sound normal.
    When you use a social norm, make it truthful and pair it with clear approval of the desired behavior.

    If your data support it, you might say:

    Most employees report suspicious messages when something doesn’t look right. Thank you for helping protect your coworkers.

    What if the desired behavior is not common yet?

    Don’t invent a statistic. State the standard:

    Reporting a suspicious message is exactly the response we want. Every report helps protect the people around you.

    Try this: Review one message about poor behavior. Does it make the problem sound normal—or the solution?


    The Bottom Line

    These studies examine different problems, but they point in the same direction:

    Performance depends on more than content.
    People must notice what matters. They must recall it when needed, see a reason to act, have a workable path, and believe the behavior belongs here.

    Training can help.

    But it cannot repair a cluttered design, bring an empty mandate to life, remove a broken process, or overpower a culture that rewards the wrong behavior.

    Sometimes the smartest move is to improve the training.

    Sometimes it is to fix what stands in the way.

    What workplace learning problem should I investigate next?

  • Stop Calling It Mandatory Training

    Stop Calling It Mandatory Training

    An email lands in your inbox with the subject line Mandatory Annual Compliance Training—Complete by Friday.

    Before you open it, you already know the plot: a slow march through policy slides, a quiz designed to prove you were technically present, and perhaps a cheerful stock photo of coworkers pointing at a laptop.

    The course may surprise you. But the label may already be working against it.

    “Mandatory” tells people why the organization needs the training completed. It does not tell them why the training matters, what problem it will help solve, or what they will be able to do afterward.

    That is an administrative fact, not a value proposition. And yet we keep putting it in the headline.

    The Requirement Is Fixed. The Framing Is Not.

    People do not approach training as blank slates. They make fast judgments before the first screen loads. Will this be useful or irrelevant? Worth my attention or safe to skim?

    The word mandatory makes that judgment easier. It places the training in the same mental bucket as expense reports, password resets, and forms that need three signatures. It answers the organization’s question—Do you have to do this?—while ignoring the learner’s question: What will this help me do, avoid, or understand?

    A mandate may secure participation. It does not guarantee the motivation needed to learn or apply anything.

    That is why required learning still needs positioning. Marketers rarely lead with the least appealing part of an offer. A gym does not advertise, “Pay us to sweat before work.” A financial planner does not promise, “Several forms and an uncomfortable discussion about death.” They lead with the outcome: more energy, less stress, a safer future.

    Learning teams should do the same. You do not need to hide the requirement. You simply need to demote it. Lead with the reason to care, then include the deadline and completion rules as supporting details.

    Change the Frame

    Compare these announcements:

    Before: Complete Cybersecurity Training
    After: Protect Your Team From the Attacks Employees See Most Often

    Before: Annual Code of Conduct Training
    After: Know What to Do When the Right Choice Is Not Obvious

    Before: Required Manager Training
    After: Handle Difficult Performance Conversations Without Making Them Worse

    Before: Mandatory Data Privacy Course
    After: Avoid the Small Data Mistakes That Create Big Problems

    Nothing about the requirement changed. The stronger versions simply make a more useful promise.

    They give people something concrete to care about: a threat, a decision, a mistake, or an action they will be better prepared to take. The message shifts from “the company wants this” to “this could help me.”

    Of course, the promise must also be true. Do not advertise the “most common attacks” if the course never identifies them. Positioning is not decoration. It is a clear and honest connection between what people need and what the learning experience delivers.

    Four Better Ways In

    When you write your next training announcement, try entering through one of these four doors. They overlap, and that is fine. Choose the one that offers the strongest truthful reason to care.

    Relevance: Where will people use this?
    Spot the phishing tactics appearing in employee inboxes.

    Risk: What costly mistake can they avoid?
    Learn the warning signs that can prevent one rushed click from exposing customer data.

    Benefit: What becomes easier, safer, or less painful?
    Prepare for performance conversations that are clearer and fairer for everyone.

    Action: What will people be able to do?
    Submit expenses correctly the first time and avoid delays or rejected reports.

    Notice that none of these promises fun. They promise usefulness, which is a much better bargain.

    Positioning cannot turn a bad course into a good one. Clever copy attached to a bloated click-through course is not marketing; it is camouflage. But poor positioning can make genuinely useful training feel worthless before it begins.

    The Five-Second Test

    Before you publish your next announcement, remove the words mandatory, required, compliance, and complete. Then read what remains.

    Can someone tell why the training matters? Can they picture a situation where it might help? Is there a clear risk, benefit, or useful action?

    Most importantly, would the message have any pull if nobody were tracking completion?

    If not, you have written an instruction rather than a reason to pay attention. You may still get a green completion dashboard, but do not confuse that with learning.

    Try This This Week

    Find one announcement that begins with Required, Mandatory, or Complete. Rewrite its headline around relevance, risk, benefit, or action.

    Keep the requirement in the message. Just stop asking it to do the work of the value proposition.

    The course may have to be mandatory. The boredom does not.

    Go Deeper

    The Evidence on Mandatory Training Is Thinner Than You Think
    This government review examines whether required workplace training in areas such as cybersecurity, privacy, ethics, and harassment actually changes performance.

    Why “You Must” Can Make People Push Back
    Explore the research on psychological reactance and why controlling language can create resistance to a message.

    A Better Way to Communicate Requirements
    See how meaningful explanations and autonomy-supportive language can preserve motivation even when a request is not optional.


    Want to Train Like a Marketer?
    If this kind of thinking hits home, you’ll probably enjoy our book Think Like a Marketer, Train Like an L&D. It’s packed with practical, real-world ideas to help you make your learning clearer, sharper, and a whole lot more effective.

  • Attention Isn’t Given. It’s Spent.

    Attention Isn’t Given. It’s Spent.

    Learners aren’t losing the ability to pay attention.

    They’re making rational decisions about where to spend it.

    That’s not a capacity problem. It’s a design problem.

    Attention Is a Resource. Not a Reflex.

    Herbert Simon saw it coming in 1971. A wealth of information creates a poverty of attention. His point was precise: information doesn’t just compete for your learners’ attention. It consumes it. And attention, like money, gets allocated — not lost.

    Daniel Kahneman confirmed the mechanism two years later. His research showed that people direct their focus based on perceived importance – not randomly, not based on elapsed time, but on whether the next moment seems worth it.

    This isn’t attention deficit. It’s rational economics.

    The Numbers Everyone Gets Wrong

    Two numbers often drive the attention conversation in L&D right now. One is fabricated. One is real and widely misread.

    The real one: 47 seconds. 
    Gloria Mark at UC Irvine tracked screen-switching behavior for two decades. In 2004, people averaged 2.5 minutes on a task before switching. Today: 47 seconds, replicated across five independent studies. Philip Guo analyzed 6.9 million edX video sessions and found engagement collapses at 6 minutes — videos over 12 minutes got roughly 3 minutes of actual watch time.

    The fabricated one: 8 seconds, shorter than a goldfish.
    A 2015 Microsoft report cited a nonexistent source. It spread because it felt true. It wasn’t.

    These numbers get called attention limits. They aren’t. They’re exit decisions.

    A learner who switches screens at 47 seconds has made a judgment: not worth it. The one who stops a video at 3 minutes has made the same call. Attention followed value until the value ran out. Then it went somewhere that offered more.

    That behavior has a name. L&D built a model around it in the 1980s. Then mostly forgot it.

    L&D Had the Answer. Forgot It Anyway.

    ​John Keller’s ARCS model — Attention, Relevance, Confidence, Satisfaction — was built directly on Expectancy-Value Theory. The equation is blunt: motivation equals expectancy times value. Either factor hits zero, engagement hits zero. Not a drift. A cliff.

    Research on relevance interventions confirms it.

    When learners understand why content matters to them personally, engagement jumps across every measure.

    Keller wasn’t describing good design. He was describing the entry fee.

    The field had this for forty years and reached for a 10-minute timer instead anyway.

    Marketers didn’t have that luxury. Their feedback loops — click rates, bounce rates, conversion data — made getting attention wrong immediately visible and immediately painful. That forced one rule above all others: earn attention before you spend it. L&D never faced that reckoning. So myths filled the void.

    The Harder Question

    Before you build anything, ask this:
    ​
    why would a learner believe the next 45 seconds is worth their attention?

    Not whether the content matters. You know it does. Whether they’ll feel it in the opening moment, before you’ve done anything to earn their focus.

    That’s your actual design problem. Not length. Not format. Not which authoring tool.

    For eLearning: lead with stakes, keep it short (ideally under 6 minutes, if possible), and cut anything that doesn’t earn its place. Your learner is running a live cost-benefit call. Win it early or don’t win it.

    For ILT and VILT, the research is consistent: attention in live learning tracks the instructor, not the clock. Relevance, interactivity, and stakes. Those are the levers. A timer is not.


    Worth Your Attention

    Interest Matters: The Importance of Promoting Interest in Education

    This research highlights that fostering learner interest is not a superficial “nice-to-have” but a core engine for deep cognitive processing, persistence, and performance.

    ​Discover the 4 Interventions Driving Real Engagement →


    Designing Organizations for an Information-Rich World

    Worth reading, not because it’s practically actionable, but because it reframes the whole problem: attention isn’t something that’s been damaged by technology. It was always scarce. Technology just made the competition for it visible. Short, readable, historically significant.

    ​Learn Why Attention Was Always Scarce →


    Keller’s ARCS Model of Motivational Design

    This outlines a systematic blueprint for shifting the instructional focus from purely environmental rewards to a learner’s active desire to learn.

    ​Explore the ARCS Model to Design for Motivation →

  • The Dual Coding Problem: Why Your Learners Keep Tuning You Out

    The Dual Coding Problem: Why Your Learners Keep Tuning You Out

    How Dual Coding Theory Explains (and Fixes) Your Biggest Learning Design Problem

    Your learners look glazed over. They’re reading ahead while you talk. Or they’ve checked out entirely.

    You know what they’re doing? Choosing.

    Read the slide or listen to you. Not both. They can’t. And it’s not their fault—it’s your design.

    Your Brain Processes Information Through Two Separate Systems

    In 1971, psychologist Allan Paivio proposed dual coding theory. The core insight: your brain has two distinct processing channels. One handles visual and spatial information—images, diagrams, animations. The other handles verbal information—language and words.

    The critical detail most people miss? It’s not about eyes versus ears.

    Text on a slide gets processed through the verbal channel, even though you see it with your eyes. Your brain recodes written words into linguistic form. So when you put bullet points on screen and read them aloud, you’re forcing the verbal channel to process identical information from two sources simultaneously.

    Think of two conveyor belts feeding into working memory. One carries visual representations. The other carries language. When each belt carries complementary information, learning compounds. You get multiple retrieval pathways, stronger encoding, better recall.

    But pack identical information on both belts? The system jams.

    Richard Mayer’s multimedia learning research confirmed this. People learn better from words and pictures together than from words alone—but only when those words and pictures complement rather than duplicate each other.

    The Redundancy Trap

    Most training designers make the same mistake: text on slide, narration reading that text.

    You’ve seen it. Probably done it.

    The problem isn’t repetition for emphasis. The problem is cognitive cost. Your verbal processing system has limited capacity. Force it to handle the same information from two sources—reading and listening—and you max out that capacity on redundant processing. No room left for understanding.

    This is the redundancy effect. Your learners have to choose: read or listen. They read faster than you speak, finish the slide, then wait. You’re talking to people who’ve mentally moved on.

    For novice learners especially, this matters. Experts can handle more complexity. But people learning something new need clean separation between visual and verbal channels.

    Dual Coding Done Right

    This BrightCarbon video demonstrates the difference perfectly.

    First, they show the problem: slides packed with text while narration repeats those exact words. Then they flip it. Visual sequences—diagrams, animations, process flows—paired with narration that explains rather than repeats.

    Watch how it works. The visuals aren’t decorative. They’re not self-explanatory either. You need both channels. What you see plus what you hear creates the complete understanding.

    That’s dual coding working as designed.

    Redesigning Your Materials

    Stop treating slides as a script. They’re a visual partner to your narration.

    Instead of bullet points repeating your words:
    Show diagrams illustrating relationships. Use process flowcharts while you walk through steps verbally. Display before/after comparisons while you explain what changed.

    Instead of definitions on screen:
    Show examples or illustrations while you speak the definition. Visual representation through the eyes, explanation through the ears.

    Instead of spelling out your message:
    Let visuals do visual work and narration do verbal work. Explaining why customer complaints spike in Q4? Show the graph of complaint volume over time. Don’t write “complaints spike in Q4” on the slide. Your words explain why. The visual shows what.

    The principle: related but distinct information through each channel. They support each other, don’t duplicate.

    Try This

    Find one slide where you’re reading on-screen text verbatim.

    Remove that text. Replace it with a visual—diagram, icon, image, data visualization. Practice delivering it with the visual carrying its message while your narration carries yours.

    You’ll know it works when the slide alone doesn’t tell the full story and your narration alone doesn’t paint the full picture. Together, they create understanding neither could achieve alone.

    That’s how your learners’ brains want to process information. Stop fighting it.


    References:

    • Paivio, A. (1971). Imagery and Verbal Processes. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
    • Paivio, A. (1986). Mental Representations: A Dual Coding Approach. Oxford University Press.
    • Clark, J. M., & Paivio, A. (1991). Dual coding theory and education. Educational Psychology Review, 3(3), 149-170.
    • Mayer, R. E. (2009). Multimedia Learning (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • Most Instructional Designers Put This at the Start. Here’s Why YOU Shouldn’t!

    Most Instructional Designers Put This at the Start. Here’s Why YOU Shouldn’t!

    You spent three weeks on that compliance module. Got the objectives perfectly clear. Slide two, exactly where Gagne said they should be. Your instructional design was textbook.

    Then you watched what happened: Learners skimmed the objectives and jumped ahead. Exit interviews revealed the pattern: “I knew what I was supposed to learn, so I didn’t pay attention to how.” Poor retention. Minimal application on the job.

    Meanwhile, your colleague’s module—the one that starts with no objectives, just a failure scenario—had learners leaning forward, engaged, completing it in one sitting. Quiz performance was stronger. Six months later, managers reported better application.

    It breaks every rule you were taught.

    It works anyway.

    Why?

    The answer isn’t about engagement tactics or making training “fun.” It’s about something most instructional designers fundamentally misunderstand about how curiosity affects learning.

    We think curiosity is the appetizer. It’s actually the main course.


    The Conventional Wisdom Makes Perfect Sense

    Robert Gagne’s Nine Events of Instruction have anchored systematic design for 40 years. For good reason. Event #2—”State the Objectives”—makes logical, ethical sense:

    Learners deserve to know what’s expected. Objectives reduce anxiety. Clear expectations help learners organize information. Transparency respects their time.

    Every instructional design certification teaches this. Every ADDIE process includes it. Lead with learning objectives? You’re being a responsible designer.

    You’re also sabotaging the learning.

    Not for the reason you think.


    What We Got Wrong About Curiosity

    Most of us carry the same assumption: Curiosity is an engagement tactic. Gets attention. Makes training feel less boring. It’s the motivational wrapper around the real content.

    Curiosity = appetizer.
    Learning = main course.

    That’s backwards.

    What if curiosity isn’t decoration for learning—what if curiosity is how learning happens?


    What Loewenstein Actually Discovered

    In 1994, Carnegie Mellon psychologist George Loewenstein published research that should have changed everything.

    Most people know the sound bite: curiosity is a “cognitive itch.”

    They miss why that matters.

    Loewenstein showed that curiosity isn’t a personality trait. Not a motivational boost. It’s a specific cognitive state triggered by a knowledge gap—the uncomfortable distance between what you know and what you realize you must know.

    The itch only happens when you perceive something’s missing.

    The critical insight: Curiosity requires just enough knowledge to recognize that the gap exists.

    Too little knowledge? Confusion.
    Too much knowledge? No gap.
    Curiosity lives in between.

    Most training never enters that zone.

    Lead with learning objectives? You fill the hole before learners know there’s a hole to fill. You answer questions they haven’t asked yet. You solve problems they don’t feel.

    The gap closes before it opens.


    The Thing We’ve Been Getting Wrong

    The conventional wisdom: Curiosity captures attention, then objectives structure the learning.

    Curiosity = motivation.
    Objectives = learning architecture.

    The research tells a different story.

    Twenty years after Loewenstein’s psychological framework, neuroscientists at UC Davis finally measured what curiosity does to memory. Matthias Gruber, Bernard Gelman, and Charan Ranganath put people in a brain scanner and had them learn trivia facts—some they were intensely curious about, others they didn’t care about at all.

    The results were clear.

    When people were curious, their brains showed two things: First, the same reward circuits that activate for food or money lit up for information. Curiosity isn’t just mental—it’s rewarding at a neurological level.

    Second, and more importantly, the brain regions involved in memory formation showed dramatically enhanced activity.

    Curious brains form stronger memories.

    But here’s the finding that changes everything:

    The memory enhancement wasn’t limited to the information they were curious about. When learners were in a curious state, they formed stronger memories for related information too—including details they weren’t specifically trying to learn.

    Your compliance module just changed.

    When you open with a knowledge gap about the $2M invoice error—before you explain the approval process—you’re potentially creating the same memory-enhancing state Gruber observed in the lab. While the research tested trivia, the underlying mechanism appears domain-general: the brain doesn’t distinguish between “curiosity about Beatles trivia” and “curiosity about approval checkpoints.” It responds to the knowledge gap itself.

    The evidence suggests that curiosity-driven learning creates conditions where information sticks more effectively—not just the answer to the question, but the surrounding procedures, policies, and protocols you teach while learners are actively working to close the gap.

    Loewenstein predicted this in 1994. Psychology.
    Neuroscience confirmed it in 2014. Biology.
    Most instructional designers still haven’t caught up.

    Watch what happens in real time:

    The learner sees three URLs. Almost identical. One cost $2M.

    I know URLs. I know phishing. But I don’t know WHICH character matters.

    Prior knowledge: activated.
    Gap: perceived.

    They lean forward. Character by character. Domain by domain. What am I missing?

    Questions generated.
    Attention locked.

    When they spot it—that tiny subdomain difference—resolution floods in.

    There.

    That’s when memory formation happens most effectively. Not when they read the objectives slide listing “three types of phishing patterns to identify.” When they discover the pattern themselves while actively hunting for it.

    That’s not engagement theater.

    That’s learning.

    The curiosity gap creates the conditions for deep processing—the productive mental work of building understanding that lasts.

    Lead with objectives? Learners passively receive information.
    Lead with gaps? They actively construct meaning.

    This is why the “wrong” design wins.

    Not because it’s more engaging. Because the design creates the cognitive conditions where memory formation is most effective.


    The Gagne Question: Is This a Contradiction?

    If you’re a Gagne loyalist—and if you’ve been trained in systematic instructional design—this sounds like throwing out proven frameworks for trendy engagement tactics.

    It’s not.

    Loewenstein didn’t disprove Gagne. He updated him with 30 years of neuroscience Gagne didn’t have in 1985.

    Gagne was right that learners need objectives. Right that systematic design matters. Right that structure reduces cognitive load.

    He just put Event #2 in the wrong spot.

    Gagne assumed learners needed the destination before they’d take the first step. Loewenstein proved they need to want the destination first.

    The objectives aren’t wrong.
    The timing is.

    The synthesis instructional design has been missing:

    Keep Gagne’s structure. Create Loewenstein’s gap. Flip the sequence.

    Traditional approach:

    1. State objectives (Event #2)
    2. Present content
    3. Practice
    4. Assess

    Updated approach:

    1. Activate schema (give just enough context to perceive the gap)
    2. Open the gap (present the failure, anomaly, or question)
    3. Sustain the gap (reveal information gradually as they work to close it)
    4. Close the gap (NOW state the objectives—as the earned answer)
    5. Transfer the gap (create a new scenario where they apply the pattern)

    The objectives still exist. Still provide structure and clarity.

    They’re just repositioned as the answer to a question the learner is already asking.


    The Implementation Problem: Why Most Designers Get This Wrong

    Some designers try this once and fail.

    What usually goes wrong? They confuse mystery with confusion—threw learners into a vague scenario where nobody knew what domain they were in, what to pay attention to, or whether they could even solve the problem, and working memory collapsed under the weight of too many unknowns competing for too few cognitive resources.

    The training didn’t just fail to engage. It actively overwhelmed.

    Then they concluded: “Curiosity gaps don’t work. Gagne was right all along.”

    But that’s like saying vegetables don’t work because you served raw, unwashed potatoes.

    The implementation was wrong. Not the principle.

    Loewenstein’s research was clear. Curiosity only works when the gap is:

    • Perceivable (learners can tell what they don’t know)
    • Specific (the missing information is bounded, not infinite)
    • Closeable (learners believe they can find the answer)

    You can’t just throw learners into ambiguity and hope curiosity emerges. You need just enough frame to direct attention without spoiling the answer.

    The frame prevents confusion. The gap triggers curiosity.

    Compare these:

    Bad gap (creates confusion):

    “Here’s a $2M invoice error. Figure out what went wrong.”

    What domain? Accounting? Data entry? Fraud?
    What am I looking for? Everything? One thing?
    Can I even solve this with what I know?

    Anxiety spikes. Working memory overloads.

    Good gap (creates curiosity):

    “Three people approved this invoice before it went out. The amount was wrong from the first click. Your job: find which approval checkpoint failed—and why everyone missed it.”

    Domain: clear (approval process)
    Task: specific (identify the failed checkpoint)
    Scope: bounded (it’s about process, not everything)
    Gap: present (I don’t know which checkpoint or why it failed)

    The second version gives learners orientation without answers. They know what to pay attention to. They don’t know what they’re going to discover.

    That’s where curiosity lives.


    Why Your SME Will Hate This (And How to Win Them Over)

    The SME conversation usually goes like this:

    “Why waste time on mystery? Just tell them what they need to know.”

    Fair objection.

    Here’s the reframe:

    When you lead with answers, you’re adding to the pile of 2,000 things they’re supposed to remember. Most of it disappears within a week—you’ve seen the post-training assessment data.

    When you lead with the problem, something different happens. The information you give them isn’t competing with 2,000 other facts. It’s the answer to a question they’re actively trying to solve. Research shows memory formation is more effective when learners encounter information in a curious state—when they’re working to close a knowledge gap.

    The SME’s content doesn’t change. The sequence does.

    You’re still giving them all five vulnerability types. Still covering every approval checkpoint. Still delivering the same expertise.

    We’re just repositioning it from “information to memorize” to “answer to a problem they’re trying to solve.”

    And the sequence determines whether their expertise becomes information that fades or knowledge that sticks.


    The Working Memory Question You Can’t Ignore

    Picture your learner staring at that objectives slide.

    Their brain is working. But on what?

    Reading the bullet points. Trying to figure out why this matters. Wondering when the real content starts. Checking Slack.

    That’s mental effort. But it’s not productive mental effort. It’s not building understanding. It’s just… busy work for the brain.

    Cognitive load theory has a name for this: extraneous load. Mental effort wasted on poor design instead of directed toward learning.

    Now picture the same learner encountering the $2M invoice error scenario.

    Their brain is still working. But now it’s working on: What checkpoint failed? Why did everyone miss it? What pattern am I not seeing?

    That’s also mental effort. But this time, the effort IS the learning.

    Current cognitive load theory distinguishes between two types of load:

    Intrinsic load (inherent complexity of the material)—UNAVOIDABLE
    Extraneous load (wasted mental effort from poor design)—ELIMINATE THIS

    The goal isn’t to reduce all cognitive load. It’s to eliminate wasteful load so learners can direct their limited working memory toward productive cognitive processing.

    Create a boring objectives slide? Extraneous load.

    Create a confusing, unbounded mystery? Also extraneous load.

    Create a bounded, directed knowledge gap? You minimize extraneous load while creating optimal conditions for learning.

    The critical factor: Working memory capacity is limited. Research suggests we can hold about four chunks of information at once. During a curiosity gap, learners are holding:

    1. The question or problem
    2. Their activated prior knowledge
    3. Attention to relevant cues
    4. Meta-cognitive monitoring

    Manageable—if you’ve provided the frame.

    Without the frame? Add uncertainty about domain, confusion about task, anxiety about solvability. Working memory exceeds capacity. Extraneous load spikes. Confusion replaces curiosity.

    The design principle:

    Bounded + directed + solvable = optimal conditions for learning.


    From Theory to Monday Morning: Redesigning Your Next Module

    You probably have a module you’re working on right now.

    Compliance training. Technical onboarding. Soft skills development.

    Right now, it probably starts with objectives. A dutiful list of what learners will know and be able to do.

    Your redesign framework:

    Phase 1: Don’t Delete the Objectives—Delay Them

    Your objectives aren’t wrong. Just premature. Move them from slide 2 to the moment after learners have encountered the problem the objectives solve.

    Phase 2: Replace Event #2 with “Frame the Gap”

    Open with three elements:

    1. Domain specification (what realm are we in?)
    2. Specific question (what don’t I know?)
    3. Bounded scope (how big is this problem?)

    Traditional objectives: “By the end of this module, you will identify three types of phishing URLs and explain how each exploits user behavior.”

    Framed gap: “Three employees clicked three different links last month. One lost their password. One leaked quarterly forecasts. One triggered a $2M breach. The URLs looked almost identical. Your job: find what the security team missed.”

    Same learning outcome. Different entry point.

    One spoils the answer. One creates the itch to know.

    Phase 3: Reveal Information Gradually

    Don’t dump the content. Unfold it.

    Let learners predict before you explain. Show examples before you give the pattern. Make the resolution earned rather than delivered.

    Phase 4: State Objectives as Resolution

    NOW—after they’ve wrestled with the problem—tell them what they just learned:

    “Those are the three phishing patterns most employees miss: subdomain spoofing, homograph attacks, and URL parameter injection. You just learned to identify all three in context. Now let’s practice on new examples.”

    The objectives become the answer, not the assignment.


    The One Thing to Audit Right Now

    You don’t need to redesign your entire curriculum today.

    Start with one diagnostic question:

    In your next module, are you answering questions learners haven’t asked yet?

    If yes, you’ve found your gap opportunity.

    The fix isn’t complicated. It’s sequential. You’re not removing information. You’re reordering when it appears.

    I’ve built a tool that walks you through exactly how to audit your modules for curiosity gaps—and how to redesign them without starting from scratch.

    Try the Curiosity Audit:

    curiosity-audit.lovable.app

    It’ll show you where you’re spoiling answers, where you’re creating confusion instead of curiosity, and where you’re missing opportunities to turn passive content into active problem-solving.


    The Bigger Picture

    This isn’t about making training “fun.”

    Not about engagement metrics or completion rates.

    It’s about designing for how memory actually works.

    The research is clear: Curiosity creates conditions where memory formation is enhanced. When you create the gap first, you’re not just capturing attention—you’re creating the conditions where the information you worked so hard to design actually sticks.

    The question isn’t whether to use systematic design or curiosity-first design.

    It’s how to synthesize both.

    Structure that creates productive cognitive processing instead of passive information consumption.

    If you aren’t digging holes before you fill them, you aren’t teaching. You’re just reciting.

    Your next module starts Monday.

    Slide two is waiting.

    What will you do with it?


    References

    Gagné, R. M., Briggs, L. J., & Wager, W. W. (1992). Principles of instructional design (4th ed.). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College Publishers.

    Gruber, M. J., Gelman, B. D., & Ranganath, C. (2014). States of curiosity modulate hippocampus-dependent learning via the dopaminergic circuit. Neuron, 84(2), 486-496. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2014.08.060

    Loewenstein, G. (1994). The psychology of curiosity: A review and reinterpretation. Psychological Bulletin, 116(1), 75-98. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.116.1.75

    Sweller, J., van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Paas, F. (2019). Cognitive architecture and instructional design: 20 years later. Educational Psychology Review, 31(2), 261-292. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-019-09465-5


    Want more like this? The thinking in this post comes from Think Like a Marketer, Train Like an L&D Pro—a deeper dive into applying behavioral science and marketing psychology to learning design.

    #TrainLikeAMarkter #InstructionalDesign #LearningScience #CuriosityGap #CognitivePsychology

  • The Dangerous Allure of Distraction: Why Seductive Details Can Derail Learning (and When They Don’t)

    The Dangerous Allure of Distraction: Why Seductive Details Can Derail Learning (and When They Don’t)

    NOTE: I’ve updated this post from the previous version to incorporate some new research shared by Julie Dirksen & Will Thalheimer.

    Every learning designer knows the temptation.

    You’ve built a solid course… but it still feels a little flat.
    So you add a funny story.
    Or a dramatic photo.
    Or a splash of background music because “engagement!”

    And just like that, you’ve stepped into one of the most reliable traps in instructional design: the seductive details effect—where interesting but irrelevant extras quietly pull attention away from the actual thing you need people to learn.

    It’s one of those ideas that sounds small but has outsized consequences. And thanks to decades of research, we now know a lot more about when seductive details hurt learning, why they do it, and the few situations where they’re not as dangerous as they seem.

    Let’s break it down.


    Why Seductive Details Are So… Well, Seductive

    Our brains love novelty. Tiny surprises. Little emotional jolts. Anything that fires up curiosity.

    But in learning, that thrill comes at a cost.

    When you add content that’s fun but not necessary—like a quirky anecdote or a dramatic image—it forces the brain to split attention. Working memory is limited, and every extra bit of processing devoted to something irrelevant is attention not available for the concepts that actually matter.

    And the hit isn’t small.
    Across studies, irrelevant details reduce learning by an average of 15–40%, and the effect is even stronger when visuals and text fight for space on the same screen.

    The punchline:


    What’s New (and Why the Story Isn’t as Simple as “Never Add Anything Fun”)

    Older research painted seductive details as almost always harmful.
    Newer research gives us a more realistic picture.

    Here’s the nuance:

    1. Prior knowledge matters. A lot.

    Novices get derailed easily. Their working memory is already full, so even small distractions knock them off track.

    But experts? They can often handle a decorative detail or two because they already have mental models to fall back on.

    2. Motivation and emotion change the equation.

    Seductive details can boost interest and reduce boredom—especially in long, self-paced programs.

    That emotional lift might help people stick with a course they’d otherwise abandon.

    3. The “dose” and placement make a huge difference.

    A single visual at the periphery? Probably fine.

    A funny sidebar next to a complex diagram? Probably not.

    A story that runs longer than the actual lesson? Definitely not.

    4. The effect is strongest in high-load content.

    If the topic is complex, dense, or unfamiliar, even tiny distractions pull cognitive resources away from meaning-making.

    5. The research you often see quoted comes from very short lessons.

    Most classic seductive-detail studies use 3–5 minute learning segments followed by immediate tests—not the messy, multi-hour reality of workplace learning.

    So: the effect is real, but size and severity vary.


    So When Can You Use Seductive Details Without Wrecking Learning?

    Here’s the short list:

    • When learners already know enough to handle a little extra.
    • When motivation is the bigger barrier than comprehension.
    • When the detail creates emotional connection and you place it away from core content.
    • When the detail helps build a metaphor that actually clarifies meaning.

    Everything else? Probably not worth it.


    What to Do Instead: Design for Cognitive Interest, Not Entertainment

    If you want engagement that builds learning instead of derailing it, focus on what researchers call cognitive interest—the kind of curiosity that points people directly at the idea you want them to understand.

    Here are safer, stronger design moves:

    Use visuals with a job.

    Show relationships. Reduce complexity. Guide the eye.

    Skip the clip art holding a magnifying glass.

    Build relevance, not decoration.

    A scenario that mirrors the real workplace beats a funny aside every time.

    Use contrast and clarity to draw attention.

    People engage longer when content feels simple to navigate and easy to grasp.

    Space key ideas across time.

    Your best “engagement hack” is giving the brain room to breathe.

    If you do add a story, keep it tight and directly connected to the learning point.

    You don’t need a Marvel-level backstory. One crisp, relevant setup is enough.


    The Bottom Line

    Seductive details aren’t evil. They’re just expensive.
    Sometimes the cost is worth paying—most of the time, it isn’t.

    If your goal is learning that sticks, the safest bet is always the same:

    Be intentional.
    Be relevant.
    Make the learning effortless to follow, and every detail earns its place.

    Add delight, not distraction.
    Add meaning, not noise.
    That’s how you design content that respects attention—and actually gets results.